Quoted By:
It's important to note that opinions about video games, including the "Dark Souls" series, can vary widely among players, and what is considered the "worst" entry in the series is subjective. That being said, there are a few reasons why some players view "Dark Souls 2" as the weakest installment in the series:
Different Directorial Vision: "Dark Souls 2" was directed by Tomohiro Shibuya and Yui Tanimura, while the first and third entries were directed by Hidetaka Miyazaki. Miyazaki's unique design philosophy and attention to detail were a significant part of what made the original game so well-regarded. Some players felt that the change in directorial vision led to a departure from the aspects that made the first game special.
Level Design: The level design in "Dark Souls 2" was often criticized for lacking the interconnectedness and sense of world cohesion that was present in the original game. Some areas felt disjointed and linear, which contrasted with the intricate shortcuts and interconnected map of the first game.
Enemy Placement and Ganks: Some players found that "Dark Souls 2" relied heavily on placing groups of enemies in tight spaces, which led to frustrating and challenging encounters that felt unfair at times. This design choice differed from the more deliberate and strategic enemy placement in the first game.
Adaptability and Gameplay Mechanics: "Dark Souls 2" introduced the Adaptability stat, which affected things like the speed of drinking Estus Flasks and the effectiveness of dodging. Some players felt that this mechanic unnecessarily complicated the gameplay and added an extra layer of complexity that wasn't as present in the other entries.
Visual and Artistic Direction: While opinions on this aspect vary, some players felt that the visual and artistic direction of "Dark Souls 2" was not as consistent or atmospheric as the other games in the series.
