>>1448900I also use the polygonal lasso tool. I don't use magic wand or quick selection. I was also looking at the PSD file you posted. it looks really god and you do the same thing I do to brown. Do you also select the outline of what you're browning or not? It looks like you don't in your PSD file.
I'll be browning this tonight. I'll post the shopped version later on. Let me know what you think afterwards.