>>2200841 #A1.
It sucks, but probably better this way. Erika never seemed to really care about who she was fucking, just using it creep people out or mess with them. I'm sure that could change, but eh.
I want to say B, but I feel like Aria will be crushed if we reach that conclusion and don't get Erika. I don't think she is bad, but I feel like we can do better. I'm just not sure who we can bond with other than Medea and not have some problems with our cat girl ness, since anyone else in our cabin is a no-go.
If anyone has a better suggestion, I am always willing to change my vote, but this is how I see it for now.