https://www.wsj.com/world/russia/russia-shuts-off-internet-in-moscow-as-it-tests-nationwide-censorship-system-3b44c0af Russia is stepping up its tests of systems designed to keep millions of people from accessing information online in times of political unrest, shutting off mobile internet access in the capital in recent days.
People in Moscow, a city of 13 million, have found themselves unable to pay online bills or message co-workers in recent days. Commuters stepping out of the city’s subway stations can’t order a cab to the office. Unable to access online maps, many are asking strangers for directions for the first time in years. Those who normally work from home are filling cafes as they seek a stable Wi-Fi connection.
In recent months, dozens of Russian regions have gone offline suddenly. The Kremlin has defended the shut-offs as necessary to protect Russians from attacks by Ukrainian drones, which can use local cellphone towers for navigation.
But analysts say what Russians are actually experiencing is the trial of a nationwide system Moscow has been honing to limit information and hobble connectivity in times of upheaval, inspired by lessons from Iran and other authoritarian states.
“This is a system they have wanted to build for years. Now the threat of Ukrainian drones is a perfect chance to test it nationwide,” said Alena Epifanova, an expert on Russia’s internet at the German Council on Foreign Relations. “They use it as a pretext, even in regions where there is no such danger.”
The shutdowns have attracted greater attention in recent days as they have hit Moscow, a city that has long prided itself on its embrace of online services. Now data outages are disrupting daily routines and businesses.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
Residents say the worst drop-offs have been happening closest to the seat of Russian power. The nearer you are to the Kremlin, the more severe the restrictions are, said a 29-year-old IT professional. Russia has been testing a system that Iran used as it sought to suppress recent protests in January. When Tehran shut down the internet to prevent people from organizing and information from leaking out, it activated a parallel internet network it had invested billions of dollars in building. So-called white SIM cards allowed regime insiders and VIPs to maintain access to the web. Russia has been honing and testing similar infrastructure for the past year. It has established a white list of government-approved sites that remain accessible during shut-offs. The sites include government portals, state media outlets, and Russian homegrown apps such as Max, a messaging platform controlled by the government. That effort has also targeted platforms Russians have relied on for years, such as the Telegram and WhatsApp messaging apps. In the past 12 months alone, Russia has blocked or throttled those apps among others and forced government institutions including schools to use Max, which tech experts say has no encryption and can be easily monitored. But the data outages have had the most immediate and far-reaching impact, extending to dozens of regions across Russia’s 11 time zones—including places far from the fighting in Ukraine. In Kamchatka, a peninsula located almost 4,500 miles from the front lines in Ukraine that hasn’t been struck by drones, the regional governor has appealed to Moscow to lift the restrictions. An official of the Ulyanovsk region west of Moscow said in November that mobile data shut-offs would likely be in place until the end of the war.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
In some regions, pharmacies have had to close as their medicine tracking system went offline. Shutdowns have caused problems for diabetic children whose sensors can’t transmit glucose levels to parents and warn them in case of emergencies. People are unable to book doctor’s appointments, order medication or use online banking to send money to elderly or disabled relatives. “This is creating a lot of problems,” said Anastasia Kuznetsova, a mother of two living in St. Petersburg, which has also suffered from outages. “In shops, delivery services, taxis and other basic services.” Ulyana Sedysheva, a mother of two from the suburbs of Ulyanovsk, said during recent shut-offs that she was unable to pay her bills and struggled to fulfill orders for customers of her online business, while her children couldn’t access online school materials for their homework. She has since set up a wired internet connection to ease the burden. In Moscow, residents say they are being taken back in time. Coffee stalls accept only cash because their payment terminals are down. Some people are buying paper maps. Sales of walkie-talkies from Russia’s main online retailer have risen 73% in the past month, according to business newspaper Kommersant. Business has been hit. Ride-hailing apps, couriers and retailers have suffered. Employees have missed urgent messages from their bosses. The outages caused five billion rubles in loss for companies in Moscow, equivalent to almost $63 million, over a period of five days, Kommersant reported Wednesday. The paper said mobile internet usage comprises 50% to 70% of internet traffic in Russia. “It’s a paradox that you can use all kinds of internet services in most of the country,” said Jonny Tickle, a British national living in Moscow. “And then you’re in the center of the capital, in full view of the Kremlin, and you can’t send a WhatsApp message.” On Wednesday, the Kremlin defended the latest shut-offs in Moscow but didn’t give a reason for them.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
“Citizens should have no doubt that the main thing here is to ensure security,” spokesman Dmitry Peskov said. Internet issues are yet another pain for Russians who are contending with rising inflation and economic strain more than four years into the war in Ukraine. The shut-offs are likely to become more frequent, analysts say. In February, Russia’s parliament passed a new law obliging telecommunication companies to shut off data access if asked to do so by the Federal Security Service, Russia’s domestic intelligence agency.
Anonymous
How much longer are the Russian people going to put up with living under a mafia state?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>1497096 They're the ancestors of communists. They'd be fine being enslaved.
Anonymous
>>1497096 Shut the fuck up mutt your country starts all the wars at the behest of Jews. The most based thing China ever did was put up the great firewall so mutt propaganda can't infect them. Go back to sucking Israeli jew dick little muttlet. You're losing in Ukraine and you're losing in Iran. How's it feel? Seething mutt. How's the gas prices at the pump? How's the pedophile government? How's the 1 trillion Mexican illegals? Retard. You absolute retard. Fix your own problems before yapping about other countries.
Anonymous
>>1497149 >your country starts all the wars Did the Allies annex Sudetenland?
Did NATO annex Crimea?
Putin annexted Crimea, and invaded Ukraine.
So thanks for admitting that Putin is Jewish
>mutt >pedophile https://www.military.com/video/off-duty/odd/akward-moments-with-vladimir-putin/3129473236001 The duality of the hypocrite.
>you're losing in Ukraine >Ivans being obliterated by non-US Storm Shadow missiles & Ukrainian drones Good Anonymous
>>1497156 >whataboutism Not him, but the ruskies being shitty people doesn't mean your administration are any better.
He's absolutely right about the US being s bunch of war mongering savages.
This entire current conflict was started by them because drumpf couldn't keep his ego in check.
Anonymous
>>1497149 >>1497157 >He's absolutely right about the US being s bunch of war mongering savages >Ivans being a bunch of warmongering savages Putin can simply withdraw from Ukraine, admit that all his opinions are more than wrong, and apart from an embassy in Kyiv & trade with that country like all other civilized countries, he doesn't have the right to so much as think of looking in the direction of Ukraine ever again if he thinks he's any better than any US administration.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
IF YOU DONT HAVE A RADIO GET ONE
Anonymous
>>1497161 >Putin can simply withdraw from Ukraine Victoria Nuland can't un-coup the Ukraine government though.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
><Russian talking points intensify>
Anonymous
>>1497244 Why would anyone want to restore the Russian puppet government from before the coup?
Anonymous
>>1497256 >Russian puppet government Victoria Nuland was literally on the ground handing out cookies during that Maidan revolution after getting caught on tape talking about regime change.
Anonymous
>>1497281 According to Russian politician Oleg Mitvol, Yanukovych bought a house in Barvikha in Moscow Oblast for $52 million on 26 February 2014.[280]
On 27 February 2014, a report stated that Yanukovych had asked the authorities of the Russian Federation to guarantee his personal security in the territory of Russia, a request that they accepted.[281] Yanukovych claimed that the decisions of the Ukrainian parliament adopted "in the atmosphere of extremist threats" are unlawful and he remains the "legal president of Ukraine". He accused the opposition of violation of the 21 February agreements and asked the armed forces of Ukraine not to intervene in the crisis. The exact whereabouts of Yanukovych when he made this statement was unclear.[282][283] In a June 2015 interview with BBC's Newsnight he thanked Russian President Vladimir Putin for "saving his life".[226]
In an April 2014 poll by Kyiv International Institute of Sociology those polled in southern and eastern Ukraine were generally split on the legitimacy of the then Yatsenyuk government and parliament, but a majority in all regions agreed that Yanukovych was not the legal president of the country.[284]
On 3 October 2014, several news agencies reported that according to a Facebook post made by the aide to the Ukrainian Interior Minister, Anton Gerashchenko, Viktor Yanukovych had been granted Russian citizenship by a "secret decree" of Putin.[285] On the same day, Russian presidential spokesman Dmitry Peskov said that he didn't know anything about this.[286]
Anonymous
>>1497298 >was removed from power after he was chased out of Ukraine >maidan revolution was in February 2014 Yeah that tracks
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>1497350 I don't know what we're agreeing about. Everything that happened between 2014-2021 was planned by the US State dept. And then the official stated policy position of the US gov was to topple Russia via war.
Anonymous
>>1497361 If the USA wanted to topple Russia the first thing it would do is give Putin the Maduro/Khameini treatment. USA is a democracy, we are a hydra. Cut off one head, and two more sprout. Russia has always had one strong leader, whether his name is Romanov, Stalin, or Putin, makes no difference
When the USA wants to destroy Russia it will start by killing Putin and no one can hide from our might.
Anonymous
>>1497368 >Russia has always had one strong leader, whether his name is Romanov, Stalin, or Putin, makes no difference That's not true though. Control of nuclear weapons are decentralized in Russia for example.
This conversation is retarded.
Anonymous
>>1497399 so you're literally russian, esl shill? lol. explains why you called me drunk
Anonymous
>>1497400 You're hallucinating again.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>1497401 no i'm not, we all see you spamming here all the time shill
The esl shill that marks your posts.
>>1497400 HEY FAGGOT, THERE'S MORE THAN ONE PERSON WHO POSTS HERE YOU MENTALLY INSANE SCHIZO FUCKFACE.
Anonymous
The esl shill that marks your posts.
>>1497405 Not especially. But your disruptive posting is useless.
Anonymous
>>1497407 i'm so sorry for disrupting your shilling and billionaire cocksucking
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>1497096 Forever, Russians, like Americans, love being slaves.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>1497096 Pretty long, but not for the childish reasons the other anons pointed out, but because the regime is so deeply entrenched and has invested a lot of resources into making sure it stays that way.
From what I understand, to many people politics and the government have become these vague foreign concepts and they don't feel like they can't change anything. Kind of like a force of nature. Would you ask someone, how long they would put up with living in the rain? Kind of the same concept.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>1497408 you're projecting again gay shill no one's sucking cock but you