Quoted By:
Coleman is shit-tier dead weight. My family used them when i was a kid for car camping. If it rains, you're fucked. And i grew up near Seattle, so....yeah that sucked.
Keep an eye out for sales at REI- I picked up one of their tents a while back for $125- a 4 person no less. Their store brand gear is actually pretty fucking good. As good as Kelty or whatever. Getting a Coleman tent because it's $50 cheaper than a decent lightweight tent is....retarded. Based on your list, def. go with ALPS.