>>1999884>I have yet to see you present a better explanation as to why history played out the way it didTry studying it, for starters.
The point with geographic determinism isn't that it's wrong, but Diamond is wrong. He puts literally everything on hard-core geo determinism, ignoring entirely every other factor imaginable. And everything that doesn't fit his "perfect" vision is instantly discarded.
Last time this style of geo determinism was done, it was 1820s, with people writing sincere works in tune of "there is coal in Wales, because God willed the rise of British mining industry".
Here, I digged out for this pasta specially for you. The guy is considered a hack for past 20 years by pretty much everyone, there are people who made their doctorates just dissecting how idiotic GGS is. Hence why I'm genuinely surprised there is anyone taking him serious anymore.
