>>2653930>doesn't get dirtyYes it does
>doesn't get smellyYes it does
>doesn't tear holes/ripNot really an issue, modern soft shell uppers are plenty resistant to mechanical damage
>warmNot nearly as modern insulated shells
>breathableWool‘s greatest advantage is wicking sweat away, but yes it is breathable, which also makes it shit for wind resistance
>non-flammableNon issue for me yet again I‘m not a retard drunkenly dancing around campfires
>still insulates when wetNot really plus it becomes incredibly heavy - membrane shells don‘t get wet in the first place
>doesn't need to be treated to maintain its propertiesIf you ever wash it, it‘s ruined
>doesn't make loud noises when you moveNeither does any modern soft touch shell worth its money
>will still look new after 10 years of abuse so you end up saving money in the long-runExcept it won‘t because you can never wash it or take care of your own gear since you need to rely on dry cleaning - also they are inevitably going to start to stink of sweat and smoke at some point and you will never be able to get rid of these smells
