>>4355242I don't have both, just the Sigma (and dozens of other nicer, worse, older, newer, wider, longer lenses).
But any prime lense that doesn't receive unequivocal praise from the based God Ken Rockwell gets a big yikes from me.
https://www.kenrockwell.com/canon/lenses/28mm-f18-sharpness.htmThose test shots are on a 12mp 5Dinosaur; I'd consider that as meme-tier softness on hp5, let alone modern digital.
What's fun about the sigma Art is the kernel of razor/digital sharpness in the middle to mid-frame, even at full aperture, combined with the strong (but not actually rock-hard-ran-out-of-image-circle) vignette. And the flexibility that if you really need across the frame sharpness, you just choose an actual landscape aperture and crop a fraction and you have it.
It means you can create a variety of image styles with the one lense, and makes it fun to shoot.
