>>14379773Because they're in AEW and Tony Khan has been the booker there for the last 5 years.
Tony has cooled off his own company. You can't expect a few new deck hands to stop the Titanic from sinking.
Sasha could go back to WWE and sell a lot more merch than she is in AEW, but she wouldn't move the needle on ratings or PPV.
Osprey could go to WWE and after a strong 12 month push probably move the needle a little bit, but nothing like Roman did.
Okada can't speak English so he'd just be a mid-card jobber in WWE. The modern Japanese Stronk style of physical charisma just doesn't work with the majority of Western audiences, and its made even worse for Okada because there would be nothing impressive about him physically in the WWE to sell that style. At least he's considered tall in AEW and has somewhat of a built in audience for the live shows, even though its not coming across with the TV audience in the ratings so far.