Quoted By:
The difference is Vader was incredibly strong, was an NFL tier athlete (literally), and could perform great feats of strength and all of his shit in the ring looked tight as hell.
Guy had a believable moveset and when he was booked properly (see his entire feud with Inoki, basically his entire Japanese run), he was one of the most believable monsters in wrestling history, right up there with Andre, Brodie, Hansen, etc.