>>15485342They are not allowed to give it back. They are required by contract to keep it on show in their homes at all times. It's a classic test of a wrestler's home decor IQ.
Masahiro Chono (known as Mr. G1 due to how many times he won it) was famously sent to work in WCW due to his wife getting rid of one of his trophies because she thought it was ugly and didn't match the drapes.