>>12101057Punk:
>Nash- 46/80:Promos 4/10. Could only cut 1 promo "lol jk idc u mad bro vanilla midget?"
Charisma 8/10. Carried himself well
Gimmick 5/10. Best as himself a lazy smartass
Matches 4/10. Could have decent bigman bashes when he cared which was maybe once a year. Otherwise dull.
Look 9/10. One of the best looks in history
Believability 7/10. Never came off as a tough guy character but with his size he always had presence
Draw 5/10. Diesel didn't draw, nWo was mostly Hogan's heel turn. Only time he drew was Wolfpac, didn't last long
Backstage 4/10. "Money & miles" is a work he's blatantly an insecure mark for himself & Shawn who seethes at criticism, contributed to WCW losing guys & going round in circles booking wise
>Punk- 50/80:Promos 7/10. Could only cut 2 promos "le insider smark reference worked shoot" or "im a better fake fighter + i <3 liberals", but gifted at making the same shit feel fresh with just charisma
Charisma 9/10. See above, material was repetitive but hid it with charisma. Had people thinking he was a legit MMA badass in 2006, carnied Dana White
Gimmick 6/10. Best as himself a self righteous smartass, but his cult leader gimmick bumps him up 1 point
Matches 7/10. Athletically lacking & cribbed most of his spots from other people, but had just enough variety, psychology & stamina to have a decent match with a lot of people or a great match with the right person
Look 6/10. Was a 7 back in 2005-07 because there weren't other people like him on WWE, but never toned up, by the end was a skinny fat old Negan cosplayer covered in tattoos, in an era full of skinnyfat dudes with shit tattoos. Went from standing out to looking like a Gen Xer trying to fit in with the kids
Believability 3/10. Carnied it to a 7 when people thought he knew Muay Thai, killed his credibility in UFC, had to rely on backstage fights to seem tough
Draw 7/10. Moves merch, bumped ratings briefly w/Summer of Punk
Backstage 5/10. Narcissist, impossible to please
