>>10011505This is correct. If it goes from good to bad, it'll just get voted worst gimmick of the year because people will forget how good it used to be. If it goes from bad to good people will think it's funny to vote both.
Arguably going by crowd reaction, Cody had a shot the year he switched back to WWE.
Alternatively, someone who gets switched to a comedy character and gets over using the same trappings as their serious gimmick for comedic effect