>>10695123I mean I wouldn't call him irredeemable personally. In the end of the day he's tall, he looks the part, he's actually a fairly decent promo and he's not outright shit in the ring. He just exudes anti-dimes for whatever reason. It definitely doesn't help that AEW kept trying to push him over and over despite the fact it clearly wasn't happening. I'm still a believer that you can turn chicken shit into chicken salad with the right booking though so I'd like to believe he could have actually gotten over to some degree if he found the right gimmick.
And no I don't think his 10 gimmick in WWE was actually over. That was an archetypical case of the chant being over and not the wrestler. And even then it was fucking moronic and it had go away heat with me the entire time he was doing it. So fucking stupid.