Honestly, he has cred and everything, he'll go into every relevant Hall of Fame, but when I look back, all I can think is that most of his good shit was his first two years in and then it's a mix of complete boredom and brief instances of something gold.
It's not like Cena, where I watched him and knew even then he was a Hall of Famer. With Orton, it's like, "I guess. He's done everything and has been there forever". So yeah, overall. But a lot of it is more on longevity, desu.