It's one thing to shit on Dave's star ratings -- completely fair, they're just opinions and all.
But the guy is a real autistic wrestling historian who knows more than pretty much anyone else alive -- every wrestler will tell you this. It's either him or Cornette, as far as being living repositories for the business' history.
I don't respect Dave's terrible taste in wrestling, particularly his fixation on luchashit and PWG style spotfest multiman tags, but I very much respect his autistic scholarship of the business.