Dusty
>Takes mix of whos and indy guys and makes them interesting
HHH
>Ruins this by signing as many indy guys as he can
>Creates PWG Fla and none of the talent actually develop into anything
Shawn
>Forced to take whos
>Somehow makes them interesting
>Spends all day on IG getting whores on the roster and uses them as valets
>HHH fucking makes them wrestle for some reason
Dusty is still the bet overall booker because he had the best balance, but I think if Shawn got some of the indy guys, that Dusty got, he'd have an overall better show. Shawn likes vignettes and shit and gives people more time than even Dusty did. HHH had the best matches, but you can argue that he failed in his position because a chunk of those guys didn't really develop into anything.