>>14046442>MJF Had the chance to be a star, they blew it with his title run, face turn, Cole team etc. Niche ironic PWG comedy doesn't draw enough.
>CassidyNot a star. Lower midcard novelty act very good at that, who they consistently cannot elevate credibly because they refuse to step away from the ironic comedy enough to do so because it still gets a reaction from the perpetually impressed AEW stand.
>AcclaimedCould have been stars, stalled out and now getting hounded by the terminally online mob AEW panders to. Cannot be stars in that environment.
>JadeYes, absolutely. But never got moved up and got fed to someone who wasn't worth it on the way out.
>Jungle BoyNot a star yet. Exposing his youthful potential as immaturity, still could be a star but long way off yet.
>>14046781>SwerveNot there yet but they have elevated him,yes.
>DarbyAll himself. He's been an OAPs lil buddy for two years, he should be their giant killer Rey Mysterio, over despite his booking.
>ToniMeme act. Got over, isn't lasting, wasn't capitalised on, out of momentum.
>LuchasaurusIs secondary to an aging Christian, has no charisma or ability to sell presence or size. Not a star.
There's only 2 actual stars on these lists and 1 they've elevated - Jade, Darby and Swerve respectively. The potential stars have either not made it there or not been capitalised on and been blown.
If WWE booked these guys people would shit on it. Same with AEWs booking of Claudio and Bryan being dogshit (and Miro despite attitude issues).
WWE fucking sucks at making stars but so does AEW. Nobody can book anymore.
