Dave Scherer already exposed Meltzer and what he used to do with ECW shows in the 90s:
"Often times, Dave would ask me for star ratings on matches in ECW. Then, when he would publish the results in his newsletter, the match ratings were different from what I had relayed to him (which luckily I had backup for since I posted reports, with the ratings, on the r.s.p-w group).
But, wrestlers didn’t know the whole story since they didn'f read the group. They would see Dave’s newsletter, my name credited, then ask me why I crapped on their match, when I certainly didn’t. How Dave got the ratings that he did, I can’t say. All I knew is that they didn’t come from me but it sure as hell looked like they did the way he presented them. That led to me starting a ridiculous group on r.s.p-w called, Mutants Against Star Ratings (some of us in the bleachers at the ECW Arena referred to ourselves as “mutants”). I gave up rating matches with stars. I decided a good writer could use, you know, words, to say how good or bad a match was and as Dave himself has shown by his own ratings, the star system is a complete joke when used by a lot of people. The big reason for stopping was simple: If I wasn’t using star ratings, no one in the business could think what Dave “reported” came from me.
There were other instances where something was reported by Dave that people in ECW assumed I was the source of when, again, that wasn’t the case."
If Meltzer lied then, he's still lying now. he never stopped making shit up. he's not even at these shows yet he contradicts people who were actually there.
