>>14502348You'll generally find that most are shredded rather than bulky. Next to your average person they will look good, but next to a bodybuilder (or wrestler) they will look toned but small. If you just cast shredded guys you'll likely be fine, because they will all look good. I would say be wary of getting a couple of bigger guys as they will show the rest up, and unless you are able to do a real national scale talent scout you wont find enough bulky guys. Like I say though, toned but small will be fine without a point of comparison to tell that they are small. Get people who look like shit for the non wrestler parts.
A play about wrestling is basically combining my 2 favourite things, so I'm buying a ticket if you get it made. Good luck