1. Ricochet
2. Bret Hart
3. Dolph Ziggler
4. Mick Foley
5. Mr. Perfect

Ricochet makes every move done to him look like something out of a video game super move without looking like comedic overselling.
Bret made every impact look believable and realistic with impact.
Dolph was a happy medium between the two above him.
Mick just let himself get hurt and it showed
Mr. Perfect was the perfect grade of overselling to make the opponent look strong.