It worked when he was a laughing heel wearing outlandish suits. Yeah it was an obvious Joker riff but there was still a masculine energy to it.
this is just your bog standard flamboyant gorgeous george gimmick BUT Seth's wardrobe is arranged by some gay black fashion guy:
https://www.instagram.com/kingtroi/He was also responsible for Becky's outfits
Problem is "gorgeous george" doesn't work with "fighting spirit workhorse babyface champion who shows up every week" Seth wants to have it both ways annd that's why he's annoying