>>15660179Gunther's aura and presence are significantly better, you could know nothing about wrestling and you'd only need a few seconds of watching him to know he's a big deal, plus he's not a complete disaster on the microphone. Claudio's a better athlete (probably good enough to play some pro sport tbqh) and is more creative with his moves/spots, but he's still just a dude doing impressive shit for the sake of it. Claudio's ceiling is jobber to the stars, but Gunther is one of the stars.
And Claudio was always better a tag wrestler anyway, one of the best of his generation.