>Michaels
Was popular as fuck at his peak, though he almost killed the company
>HHH
Pretty fucking over when he came back from his quad injury, loses points for the reign of terror
>Nash
Tanked house shows harder than nearly anyone in history, even worse than Shawn.
>Hall
Never held the big belt in either company but he was always over, and more importantly, wasn't an anti draw. Had he not been a fall down drunk and a pill hound, he may have been world champ a few times.
All said, I gotta give it to Hall. He was always dimes, didn't chase viewers away and even when he was a midcarder he was always over. After that it's Michaels, HHH, Nash, in that order.