I mean, I was the same way. When you first start digging deeper into any medium most people are going to experience this. Going from nothing but WWE style matches to anything else is going to be incredible the first time you see it.
Then you start watching even older puro, and see the actual good stuff. WCW, JCP, territories, WOS, Lucha and so on.
Then you loop back around and really start appreciating American wrestlers more. Like how good Hogan really was despite his reputation of being bad.
Seems like a pattern with most people, including myself.