>>4832324>post N64/PS1any of the Ps2 smackdown games obviously a good bet
Day of Reckoning.
SvR original, 06, or 07. 08 is garbage. 09 and 10 aren't as bad but still not my favorites. 11 is decent especially if you want a newer roster but the other 3 are still better.
The TNA Impact game is worth playing for the batshit story mode alone. Also has better graphics than even most new wrestling games. Gameplay is fun too, I like how you can reverse reversals.
I've heard picrelated (Wrestle Kingdom) is good but I've never played it because it's in all japanese
WWE All Stars is fun but gets boring unless you have friends to play it with
WWE 13 and 2k14 are good but 2k15 is immediately where it becomes shit, slows down, and becomes way more simulation based. Of the 2k games 2k14 and 2k19 are really the only good ones but I liked 2k16 because it has a Stone Cold showcase