Meltzer gave pic related 3.5 stars. AEW matches he's given at least 5 stars (as of March 2022):

Cody Rhodes vs Sammy Guevara, Dynamite 2022
Hangman Vs Danielson, Winter is Coming
Adam Cole & Young Bucks Vs Christian & Jurassic Express, Full Gear 2021
Bryan Danielson Vs Kenny Omega, Grand Slam 2021
Young Bucks Vs Death Triangle, Dynamite 2021
Kenny Omega Vs Rey Fenix, New Year’s Smash 2021
Best Friends Vs Santana & Ortiz, Dynamite 2020
Cody Rhodes Vs Dustin Rhodes, Double or Nothing 2019
FTR Vs Young Bucks, Full Gear 2020, 5.25 Stars
Young Bucks Vs Lucha Brothers, All Out 2019, 5.25 Stars
Kenny Omega VS “Hangman” Adam Page, Full Gear 2021, 5.5 Stars
Young Bucks Vs Lucha Brothers, All Out 2021, 5.75 Stars
Hangman Adam Page & Kenny Omega Vs Young Bucks, Revolution 2020, 6 Stars