>>6312271Most the matches today that Dave gives 5+ stars don't deserve it either, and most of them wouldn't get more than 3.5 stars going by Dave's standards from 20+ years ago.
That said, Roman Reigns is simply not good enough to work a 5 star match. There's no shame in that. Most wrestlers can't. But if Roman was a personal friend of Dave, he would have had multiple 5 star matches by now. Let's not pretend otherwise. He is decent in the ring, and Dave's "friend" bump is worth at least 1.5 stars if not more.