How could you have stopped your girlfriend from getting creampied by him? He could still fuck your girl if he wanted because he's a tall, charismatic, multi-millionaire who still isn't too shabby in the looks department. A young, prime Orton was a slayer. I wouldn't even try to stop Randy Orton from creaming in my girlfriend.
He's a WWE megastar, the greatest wrestler we've ever seen up to this point. He has more testosterone in his pinky finger than you have in your entire body. If he wanted to fuck your (non-existent) girlfriend, there would be literally nothing you could do to stop him.