>>7738528Assuming you mean currently active guys:
Jay White: As good a talker as MJF but with more size, works a safe style that he'll be able to work for decades without a lot of time out with injuries, can work babyface or heel, a perfect foundation for the company's main event
Darby Allin: Even if he only wrestles for another five years he has incredible underdog babyface charisma and huge crossover appeal. I would pimp the shit out of him at skating events, Hot Topic, etc.
El Desperado: Marketable look, and secretly a top five worker in the business today. Can have great matches with anybody, can work heel but also sell his ass off and get incredible sympathy as a babyface, the ace of the cruiserweight division.
Powerhouse Hobbs: Dimes look, has size, good attitude, and even if he's still green he's clearly willing to work hard to improve and even at his current level he can have the kind of matches a guy of that size should be having
Will Ospreay - Reign in his lingering flippyshitter impulses and you have another guy with size, a great look, a good promo and can work whatever type of match you need. If anyone still thinks post-clue Ospreay is a myth please watch his title match with Inushi where he doesn't use a single high flying move until halfway through the (iirc close to forty minute) match.