these lists are always bad because it just reflects the age of the people responding. Every GOAT wrestler competed post 2010 other than Misawa.
I feel like to get an actual answer to this question you need to ask legitimate boomers or people who actual watch old wrestling, like me. Since my opinions are better, and that's not an opinion that's a fact. Jack.
Take off Jericho, Mayu, Tanahashi, Guerrero, Syuri, and Omega. Insert Angle, Thesz, Nick Bockwinkel, Hogan, Tenryu, Jumbo Tsuruta
Mayu probably has a place on the women's GOAT buy Syuri isn't anywhere near that. Women can't be GOATs they don't draw other than in Japan for a few years and nobody here knows about that shit other than probably like 5 anons. Sure a bunch of people lie like they have seen a ton of 80s/90s joshi because they read some reviews and listened to Dave. Same reason Syuri made the OP list.