>>10981975On the left is the new pizza club wonk eyed Mikey with a darker skin tone and matte finish
Middle is the original run disguise four pack Mikey with lighter skin tone and a glossy finish
On the right is a later run of the disguise four pack from the Neca store again with a lighter skin tone than the pizza club Mikey but with a matte finish.
Thus none of these face parts can swap without having noticeable differences, likely by design.