>>10910072McFarlane made the best Halo line. Mafex's comes close, mostly thanks to way better articulation, but they don't look as nice.
The scale is weird as fuck, but it made sense, since they wanted to produce vehicles. If they had been 1/12, vehicles are stupidly big and costs don't actually scale 1:1, thanks the amount of space they take up.
Being 1/15 is the mid-point between the visibly better 1/12 and affordability of 1:18. If they had just gone to 1:18, the paint wouldn't look as nice, because paint application just doesn't scale down. It ends up looking like slop at 1:18.
Anyway, i really like McFarlane's covenant figures. They scale better in 1:18 than Jazware's 1:18 line, whose aliens are too small.
And you're exaggerating about the elites and QC. I bought most of my figures nearly a decade later, most in package, and haven't had a problem after buying 2 dozen of them.