>>5387753>>5387756I have both.
The comic Cap is honestly not good... at all. Limited head movement, no abdominal movement, no thigh swivel, no ankle rockers. Even the shield is of poor quality, it is a somewhat soft plastic material with no sculpted detail on the inside, and the way that it latches onto the forearm is via a poorly done plain white hook. No straps, no nothing, just a hook. The proportions are also very strange, where you have this tiny chubby-faced head, FUCKHUGE shoulders, and thin little legs. It's honestly a complete mess of a figure, and its only real redeeming factors are the gloves, boots, and the chainmail, and those things are only pluses in regards to sculpts and nothing else.
The modern movie one is, in short, fucking really cool. Everything works as it should, the articulation is comparable to a Legends figure (trade off: no double elbows; gain: true balljoint abs), the shield has two plastic straps and sculpted detail inside, and it just looks great. I wish they made more hands for him instead of the stupid display base, but whatever.
I would, however, recommend that you maybe consider the fact that Marvel Select is going to be releasing the figure as a repaint for the Civil War movie (along with Winter Soldier and Iron Man, see pic), so maybe get that one instead if you want more traditional colors.