>>5838710This one is kind of awful to me.
- All the straight lines make him look weirdly primitive and cheap, like a dollar store Transforming Robot.
- Elbows look very spindly between those massive shoulders and forearms.
- Chest is super wide and his hip joints are set comically close together, giving him this triangular 1920s strongman sorta look.
- His thighs are way too thin.
- Side skirts are awful looking.
- His hands are small for those arms and they don't have a pleasing silhouette.
The worst part to me is those shins/calves though. They're too straight and rectangular, and project back too far from his thighs as well. For some reason, it's a very important thing to me that G1 Megatrons have sloped, curving shins. I have an almost instant dislike for Megs with straight shins--the worst example I can think of right now is Toyworld's Hegemon.
Anyway, this all comes down to opinions in the end I suppose, but I think the Maketoys posted above is far superior to this one in almost every way.