Quoted By:
Listen up, butterballs. You don't get to claim both "Dark Type isn't darkness!" as well as "Luxray can't be Dark Type, because it's based on light!". That's not how this works.
Furthermore, quit ACTING like it doesn't LOOK like a Dark Type. It obviously does. Within this franchise, the monsters' elemental Types often correspond to color and visual design—And no, this doesn't mean Voltorb should be Fire/Ice because of its colors. Shut up about that, no one has ever said Luxray needs to be Dark BECAUSE it is black. We are saying it LOOKS like a Dark Type, because of its heavy black coloration. You're not allowed to call us stupid merely for noticing this, not when the creature designers constantly, deliberately, reinforce that X Type = X color.
And lastly. I don't believe Luxray should be Dark Type—it clearly wasn't intended to be an "evil creature". However, it is an aggressive-looking dark predator, and nothing has ever been said about it NOT being evil. So here's what I say: If at any point, Luxray gets a new dex entry which suggests it hunts savagely, or acts in any particularly cruel way, you all need to stop bickering immediately, and admit finally that it should have been a Dark Type.
