>>33353118I always choose Totodile for two reasons:
1. It's my favorite starter of all time and I love all of its evolutions. Too bad they fucked up all the gen 2 starter designs after GSC.
2. I love the idea of Silver stealing an innocent Chikorita and turning her into a smug delinquent Bayleef. I still remember how many times she destroyed me in Azalea town. I think this starter fits him a lot more than the others, especially when it becomes a huge man-eating dinosaur.
Anyone with good taste would choose Totodile and enjoy seeing how Chikorita is slowly corrupted by evil. That shitty fire rat can stay in Elm's lab. His final evolution looks like a total asshole anyway. He's really unlikable.