Quoted By:
Plot for Y was a 10/10 in my book. A bit saturday morning villainish, but I actually like it that way, and it was nice to have some seriously dark undertones.
Region was 6/10 for me. Big, expansive, but a tad too linear. There were very few places that it didn't just show me where to go next and it left exploration very minimal.
Legendaries are an 8/10. I'm with the people that think we have enough legendaries. We could honestly just start recycling old ones now, especially considering we have more legendaries than fire types
New pokémon were a 5/10 for me. There was a small number, and some are complete and utter shit like the keychain, but there are also some fantastic gems (Tyrantrum) in there too. Plus, i'm extremely happy they also paid attention to some of the older gens to make them more viable these days.
Challenge was a 3/10. The game was way too easy. People on /vp/ usually say I should have limited my party to 1-3 pokemon if i wanted a challenge, but if I need to actually tie my hand behind my back to make a game a challenge then it is not challenging enough.
Overall, I would give the game an 8/10, I greatly enjoy it despite some of its shortcomings.
They also made my favorite Pokémon, Mewtwo, a fucking monster again.