Quoted By:
Based on when I first played them. If I was to do it as of now Gen 2 would have FAR worse reactions.
Gen 1 - Not perfect and I wasn't hooked yet but alright. Liked Yellow better because THE STARTERZ and I was like; 6.
Crystal - I skipped G/S. Crystal was awesome at the time; although now I regard Gen 2 as the worst Gen and Jhoto as a backwater.
Ruby - Was a little sad to leave behind my bros in Crystal but liked the game in general.
Emerald - Literally the only sour point was Wallace champion
Diamond - Why are half the new pokemon unobtainable until postgame? Why is an Electric leader using an Octillery? Why is there a Fire E4 member when there are only 2 fully evolved non-legend Fire types? Why is everything so slow? Why is there no Battle Frontier?
Platinum - MERCIFUL GAMEFREAK YOU FIXED ALL THE PROBLEMS.
Heartgold - Well I guess it's better than Gen 2. Jhoto's still a backwater region however.
Black - Aw yeah let's do this N.
Black 2 - Uh wait a second this is literally the exact same midgame as Black. Bored now. Also Plasma sucks now. This is so much duller than the last game. PWT dosen't save it IMO since you actually have to get there and Gym Leader fanservice which ignores things like Giovanni is dead now and dosen't have characters age from 10+ years ago dosen't do it for me.
Y - This is cool
ORAS - This is better than Y, especially postgame... BUT WHY IS THERE NO BATTLE FRONTIER AND WHY DO YOU RUB IT IN OUR FACES?