Alright, here's the finale poll, which lists the top 5 voted Pokemon of each gen. I'll leave this up for a week again.
https://strawpoll.com/polls/NPgxkj571n2Here's a dandy list of the top 5 of each gen without having to look at the poll:
Gen 1
>Nidoking>Arcanine>Vaporeon>Kabutops>Jolteon>AerodactylGen 2
>Heracross>Crobat>Feraligatr>Ampharos>TyphlosionGen 3
>Metagross>Sceptile>Aggron>Flygon>MawileGen 4
>Porygon-Z>Weavile>Toxicroak>Torterra>EmpoleonGen 5
>Chandelure>Krookodile>Volcarona>Serperior>HydreigonGen 6
>Tyrantrum>Hawlucha>Malamar>Noivern>GoodraGen 7
>Mimikyu>Golisopod>Lycanroc>Marshadow>Alolan MarowakGen 8
>Corviknight>Grimmsnarl>Toxtricity>Dragapult>FalinksRules are all the same as the last one, except one additional rule
>If there was a tie for fifth place, I just put them both on the poll. Only really happened for Gen 1 with a tie between Jolteon and Aerodactyl