Quoted By:
There isn't a single one I would consider a peak design, I will at least say that ones I ranked in A and B are about what I would've wanted or expected for those Pokemon or at the very least is on par or better than fan designs. C Tier are fine although I've seen fan designs I like more, I also take some issue with Greninja and Floette's designs since they feel like they're encroaching on the G-Max design philosophy as opposed to what Megas tend to have (Sableye and Salamence are other Pokemon I think deviate too much).
I'm really disappointed by Clefable's mega because it's among my favourites but in comparison to others here it's far from the worst. The other D Tiers are in a similar position, I think the Mega itself is underwhelming but there are worse ones. Everything in F Tier is just shit, they're fucking ugly they ruin the original Pokemon's designs or are fucking stupid in what they decided to do for a Mega, the ones in F- especially annoy me, thanks for giving my favourite starter an absolutely horrendous mega evolution that's somehow got all the terrible elements of Duraludon combined with retarded "what if x" concepts. The Starmie one's trash as well, yeah nice Starman reference, maybe you should've actually put some effort into it though, cause it really looks like they just stretched the original model's legs making the point where they meet way too low for a Starman. Also absolutely no additions to complexify the design something most Megas even in this game do, nah we'll just leave Starmie with the gold around its eye and not add any gold or crystals to the rest of its body or any other new design features. Skarmory and Raichu's are just fucking dumb, they're not as offensive as Feraligatr's but they're completely fucking pointless and just seem like GF picked a random design element of the Pokemon that was never the focus of its design and decided to hyperfixate on it.
