>>48908043BDSP hands down, the game is held together by duct tape and a prayer.
SWSH has the power to fully function, that's my best compliment for it.
Worst part about BDSP is if you played platinum, it doesn't really replace it, and any good changes mean nothing, like "Saving a lot of data" on emulators saving is instant, so it's better to just emulate the game for free, because both the old games and new are overpriced. Hacking of the games is also getting easier so anything exclusive to BDSP will slowly just be added into those games and more making them more obsolete(and again it will be free)
I just don't think it has any real value it's a remake of a game that doesn't do enough to overtake the original(Plat) much like ORAS.
At least swsh is a unique experience until someone demakes it(probably never happen) so it has the purpose of existing.