Quoted By:
>pokemon are dumb, mindless beasts that exist for battle and entertainment
Problem with this outlook. When have we seen this? If memory serves me correctly, any time someone tries to remove a Pokemon's agency and mind, to just be a battle slave with pure power it's seen as a bad thing and is not natural. This happened with these Dark Balls for example. I can't remember a single moment where we've seen a Pokemon, naturally display this style of mentality? Ash's Pikachu for example, falls in the first option of "Sentient with the capability of intelligent thoughts". Pikachu does however act like a child most of time, which is understandable, he is a kid.