>>53941311>WaterThe shrimp one makes more sense for a Water starter and you don't see shrimp Pokemon often. Cat one looks alright, but cat Pokemon are a dime-a-dozen and thematically doesn't match Water IMO.
>FireThe frog one looks pretty bad IMO. Volcano turtle looks good, albeit a bit close to Torkoal.
>GrassGater one genuinely looks awesome, I'd use that one IRL. Chicken looks good too, but Grass/Fire doesn't make sense for a starter.
All together, Water Shrimp, Fire Turtle, and Grass Gater
