>>41916667Gen 5 was a result of Gamefreak totally misunderstanding the appeal of the brand. It's like the 1986 Transformers toys, where they killed off all the characters people liked and replaced them with new characters that often had weird, clumsy toys designed by westerners. While a lot of the things it added to the brand are beloved now, it also totally missed the fact that people are attached to the characters.
Pokemon is the same way - for all B&W contributed to the game, nobody wants to play with a fucked up ugly bird or monkey. They want to play with the Pokemon they've been attached to for over a decade. Had B&W not failed, you likely would have seen a whole new dex every Gen instead of old Pokemon being brought back.