I hadn't thought about rating starters based on their types instead of their gens, but now that i look at
>>28135746>>28135969and
>>28135987I think i'm leaning more towards water being best overall. Which is strange because i thought i disliked water.
Fire:
>GreatInfernape
>GoodCharizard, maybe Blaziken
>MehEmboar, Typhlosio, Delphox
Grass
>GreatTorterra
>GoodSceptile, Venusaur, MAYBE Chesnaught
>MehSerperior, Meganium
Water
>GreatEmpoleon, Greninja
>GoodSwampert, Feraligatr
>MehBlastoise, Samurott