>>20360998It's possible for something to be well designed and yet not appeal to a specific person.
Let's say they made a ghost/water umbrella pokemon, basing it on the yokai, except they make it resemble a modern umbrella and mixing in design cues from rainmaker spirits in other myths.
It would have a solid foundation and could even be aesthetically pleasing.
But someone who automatically dislikes object based monsters is just gonna complain about how it's a 'fucking umbrella' and hate it on that basis alone.