>>47047358based on the data I've gotten from /padt/ over the years this seems to be about where each girl stands.
Serena gets her own special tier since she's simply unrivaled in terms of reception and popularity, being /padt/'s omnipresent goddess despite not appearing for half a decade. The perfect girl
Dawn is also literally perfect and had Serena not had such a massive vocal base on /padt/ she'd be sharing the exclusive spot with Serena. alas, /padt/'s serena obsession is beyond her
PM Iris is in amazing tier because they fixed her character by playing up her strengths and ignoring everything that made her character annoying, giving her the charm and prominence she was robbed of in her series.
Bonnie. That is all.
Bs are great, but not amazing.
Cs are okay and have their moments but need more development
Ds are complete waste of a slot. Detriment to their series. Can't stand alone. need to be fixed in later seasons.