IF YOU ARE NEW PLEASE READ FAQ HERE:
http://z13.invisionfree.com/Pokemon_Gen_VP/index.php?showtopic=159 Wiki:
http://capx.wikia.com/wiki/CAPX_Wiki Forums:
http://z13.invisionfree.com/Pokemon_Gen_VP/index.php ?
Current Demo of the Game:
http://www.mediafire.com/?1de4t4u3yqg6z1z Current Comments Pastebin:
http://pastebin.com/raw.php?i=1XSUpMgD Right now we need:
>Design Revisions (For Pokemon with less then 66% approval rating) >Region details & Mapping >Names (Make sure to add your ideas to the wiki or forum!) >Sprites >Movepools, Stats & Abilities >All the rest of the dex info If you have constructive ideas for revisions, post them. If you're going to complain about the starters, don't.
Ideas are only as good as the person willing to execute them.
If you're working on maps, music, programs or art, please continue!
TO REMEMBER:
>All submissions are closed at this time! >Pokemon with Green Arrows are ready design wise to go in game, they can still be changed but your time is much better spent elsewhere. >The region is based off of South and Central America, but not everything needs to be Latin American in nature. >Yes, we are making this a game, and we're using RPG Maker to do it. >The dex has low quality images, check the wiki for better quality. >Spriters need to stop making the sprites direct copies of the art! They need to make sure they are facing the right way! > If you do not like a design give constructive criticism so we know best how to change it! >We are really trying to capture the spirit of Pokemon games. We want to make this a fun and enjoyable experience for any Pokemon player. Clash's art folder:
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/g0exdjc1rdlkg4z/dZAAdIcVGB Also SZ's Sugi'ed art so far:
http://imgur.com/a/X0x8e/#0
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
End of Probation Survey
https://www.surveymonke y.com/s/VLP 9HZG
(Make sure to read all of two questions and the blurb at the start before voting)
REDESIGN SURVEY:
https://www.surve ymonkey.com/s/Re vision6
(Some recent redesigns are not in here and will be in the next surevy)
New starter survey
https://www.s urveymonkey.com/s/have ashortsurveyforonce
Probation Surevy
http://www.surveymonke y.com/s/GDQ 8PBQ
NPC Survey:
www.surveymonke
y.com/s/NP Cs1
Anonymous
Current requirements for new demo:
Anonymous
>>12205656 someone drew this last thread.
Anonymous
>>12205656 Retrodex if anyone's bored/wants to practice spriting:
Anonymous
Wimblesaurus !HEqAdPi13w
Quoted By:
>>12205666 Did they post a game project file or a map?
Anonymous
>>12205666 That'd be me. Now with a basement.
Anonymous
>>12205694 Remember, at first only the first floor should be accessible, and it has to have some kind of Minecart puzzle (probably not on the first floor, but still).
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205643 We should cull the bug waifu
Anonymous
Here's the secret base decorations to date. If you want to contribute, please don't make any more beds; maybe help clean up the piano outlines? I tried, but it's going nowhere fast. Other furniture we could use: chairs and couches (someone mentioned beanbags?) TVs more dolls (another dozen or so would have us even with RSE's selection) interactive/animated decor (glitter rugs and whatnot. perhaps a punching bag?)
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205708 I know. Here's how I visualized it:
First Floor: entrance leads to a minecart room and the actual coal miners.
First Basement: accessed only after getting Surf. Has a few items and maybe some trainers.
Second Basement: accessed only after getting Waterfall. Has items, wild pseudos, and lava.
Anonymous
last thread somebody posted a picture on a starry cave where you can find boarealis. it was a pretty cool idea
Anonymous
Longer face for the prevo for someone that requested that in the previous thread
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12205741 Some of the dolls, chairs and tables have black outlines, while others have colored outlines (like in the real games). The difference is very noticeable, and makes them clash with everything.
Adjust the outlines of the dolls so they all have the same style.
The beds have a similar problem: their outlines are either way too bright, or non-existent. It makes them look very amateurish, and doesn't fit the style at all.
Anonymous
If there's one thing I want to see in this thread, it's a Florresum backsprite .
Anonymous
>>12205762 How about the evo having a slightly longer neck?
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205762 lower the top of the head of the prevo
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205794 I remember somebody made backsprites for the entire line.
Anonymous
>>12205686 I'm opposed to the idea of equal e4 member levels, it really takes away from the difficulty aspect, apart from not making much sense. The dragon e4 should have torn the player a new asshole by the time they reach the champion. Perhaps each of the e4s' rooms should be part of the final stretch up the mountain?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205762 Push out the chest a bit on the evo. The sunken sheck makes it look weak, passive and fat.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205752 Not included in the pic, but another idea about it was that many, many years ago (like millions), a meteor crashed into that area and "became" a mountain and the observatory was built on it.
Anonymous
>>12205791 I was told not to do further outlining on the beds or they'd stop looking fluffy, but I agree with you on the dolls. I'll go patch those up some.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205816 It's not like the level difference between e4s was much different in other games, since they were fought one after the other.
Anonymous
>>12205799 Tried. Feels like it takes away a lot from its bulk, as well as it kinds of diverts the eyes a bit. The original is easier to look at
Anonymous
>>12205834 That's o.k then, wanna cyber?
Anonymous
I'm trying to make these designs better. I changed the evo a little, but I still need to know if y'all got any ideas.
Anonymous
>>12205805 In what way? They aren't correctly scaled there, it's just for the art.
Anonymous
>>12205839 A lot of people on here seem keen on cybering, I'm sure you'll find someone else that's more willing
Also see people suggesting changes, I'm rather happy with the evo as it is
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205762 Really good, maybe the prevo's head is a tad too similar to Cranidos's, could you try a different shape? Also a normal horn for the evo, current one looks too much like Xochi's headdress.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205856 As am I, its the best design for the mon so far.
Anonymous
>>12205827 Adding outlines won't make them stop looking fluffy, it will make them look like they're actually part of the pokémon world instead of existing in a weird separate MSPaint dimension.
The pianos have the same problem.
Here's a bed from D/P. See what I mean?
Anonymous
>>12205842 Second worst mon in the dex
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205827 But it's mostly the bedframes that have problems with weak outlines. Surely the legs and bedposts aren't supposed to look "fluffy" as well?
Anonymous
>>12205876 Okay, yeah, I see it. I'll work on it after the dolls.
The same person who did the beds also did the pianos and a couple tables and left me to do all the outlining on them. I think I managed the desks okay, but I guess I'm in further over my head on the rest than I thought.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12205892 I think you need to mix more grey into the outlines. Just making them somewhat darker version of the main color rarely works, and conflicts with the traditional pokémon style (which has slightly muted colors, and a lot of grey outlines for objects and furniture).
To your defense, outlining is something that most novice spriters have a hard time with.
Anonymous
>>12205925 Comparing a D/P bookshelf and one from this homemade set. Note the muted colors and dark yet discrete outline.
Anonymous
/r/'ing the cosplaying moths for quality bro
Anonymous
>>12205848 Indricotheria are huge. Your art makes them look about the size of small horse.
Anonymous
>>12205952 Also note how the D/P sprite uses slightly darker lines near the bottom of the shelf, and somewhat lighter ones on the top. This helps the sense of depth, and is used on pretty much all Pokémon sprites.
Anonymous
>>12205978 that's one huge goat
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205960 Clash is still asleep
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>1220600 It's a bear you idiot
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206000 It's a bear, you idiot
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12206000 Or that elephant is tiny.
Anonymous
>>12205639 Do you need guys to write some of the pokedex entrys? I feel like that would be something i could do
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206025 Thanks mysterious spirit.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206025 We should cull the bug waifu
Chen !!nlrLrc/pgY6
>>12206030 Yes. Sadly I don't have a list of what needs an entry at the moment so you'll have to look through the wiki.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206027 The elephant's trunk is as long as that human is tall. The tallest elephant species in the word measures between 10-12 foot, with the more common south african elephants closer to 8-foot.
Still taller than Dragonite, but not as behemoth as they are in cultural myths
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206030 I recommend visiting the forum, even if it's mostly dead. Especially this thread:
http://z13.invisionfree.com/Pokemon_Gen_VP/index.php?showtopic=240 Anonymous
which do you like/why? any ideas for changes? any ideas to submit?
Anonymous
>>12206049 ZXCV because ease of use.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206049 Poke iPad looks p cool
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205842 the evolution is a clusterfuck. it needs to lose the palm tree face trunk, make it simpler
Anonymous
>>12205952 >>12205983 Thanks, I'll try to keep those in mind!
Anonymous
>>12206049 The top left one, I like the convenient layout. Make it less pointlessly convex and round, though. That shape doesn't really make sense for something that's designed to fit inside a pocket.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206049 thanks for bringing this up
i like
>>12206055 aswell, it references the system were using, but it looks stupid as is
im drawing another one
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206049 Fittslick needs to be in Gen 2.
Anonymous
>>12206049 i like the top left one. it have a pretty good design
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206030 Make sure you ask about the mon you're about to right a entry for so you can learn its lore. People in the past have neglected that and ended up writing things that are either wrong or dont mention important aspects. Example being some guy did Chegrin Cheshade and wrote about how fast the line was but not once mentioned their shadow tail or even knew what it was. Point being, knowing the lore is important so ask around and learn.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206049 Middle idea is bretty cool.
Anonymous
>>12206061 No problem, and you get points for not getting defensive and whiny when offered constructive criticism. It shows you're not only willing to improve, but also capable of doing so.
Anonymous
Tunnel down to the bottom floor.
Anonymous
>>12206073 >>12206062 >tfw people actually like your dex Anonymous
>>12206049 any possibility we could get a firered leafgreen style pokedex menu?
that thing was the shit.
Anonymous
>>12206089 More like it WAS shit
OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Anonymous
so what are our controlls?
are we using arrow keys and zxcv?
or zxas? or wasd?
>>12206087 (i drew the bottom 4) i know that feel, are we having a contest now, best dex wins?
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206096 thats like your opinion man.
Anonymous
>/vp/ gen >No Farfin or Tentaquil
Anonymous
>>12206098 WASD with mouse control for in battle gameplay PLEASE
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206098 see
>>12205656 The dex survey I want done soon but no later than May 15th. That'll give some people to get in their dex concepts before closing it and doing the survey.
Anonymous
>>12206104 not sure if you can change the controls, but rmxp has native controller support.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206049 Notebook and the pad look nice.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206101 >baw no le /vp/ memes ;_; Kill yourself.
Anonymous
>>12206104 >mouse control dear lord no
>>12206101 we have a reference, theres a pokemaniac dressed as tentaquil
its retards like you who pushed that
Anonymous
>>12206121 what's wrong with mouse control in battle to select your moves?
Anonymous
>>12206110 Nahh i'd rather this game actually feel like it's meant to be played on a pc, rather than me feeling like i'm emulating a gba game.
>>12206121 I mean like touchscreen bottom controls dude.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12205978 Reposting from prev thread to get a grasp of its possible size. I don't really think pokemon should have to be the size of what they're based on. It's still big
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206083 I'd probably be getting defensive and whiny if I had to deal with non-constructive criticism - there seems to be a lot of "It sucks!" and "I hate it!"s floating around with no actual suggestions for improvement. But man, I know I'm a noob at spriting, I have zero problem listening to people that know what they're doing.
Anonymous
>>12206126 >like i'm emulating a gba game. Speak for yourself, I want that feeling. Makes it much more "real" to me.
Anonymous
>>12206136 is your plan to draw so many good drawings of him we will have to use him
Wimblesaurus !HEqAdPi13w
Quoted By:
>>12206125 Nothing, that one dude's a retard.
Anonymous
>>12206142 Awkwardly using keys to scroll through bag menus and to select moves is terrible when you can just simply click on it as if you using a DS.
Anonymous
>>12206142 this
and i plan on setting my keyboard so that all the buttons are next to eachother and i can play with one hand
Anonymous
>>12205978 I imagined it being somewhat like this
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206101 check youtube for pokemon: tentaquil edition playthroughs and be grateful for the lack of tentaquil in this
Anonymous
>>12206036 i have about 20 suggestions but some of them are already taken, were do i post my suggestions?
Anonymous
>>12206160 >>one hand It's not that kind of game.
Anonymous
>>12206155 i kinda agree not really a necessity but it would be nice.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206151 Trying to show him off at least. Same with the muddy E4. Someone wondered which pokemon he'd use and I really felt in the mood for a group pic. Also, figured a fossil could work considering they are preserved in the ground, and sometimes they're even formed with the help of mud
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12206136 muddy buddy confirmed for coolest character in concept stages, would totally vote to have him in game.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206170 Doesnt matter we have no programmers and thus no hope.
Chen !!nlrLrc/pgY6
Quoted By:
>>12206167 You can post them here and the post them in the forum for safe keeping.
Anonymous
how big are our fossils going to be?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206162 Well, that's better, but the legs still look too short.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206169 clearly you havent seen ocerumi
>>12206183 undecided
Anonymous
>>12206136 >>12206177 Reposting info from previous thread as well:
Someone asked if there was more to him than just being a lover of mud so I added some stuff.
Laidback jovial guy. Was a champion in his younger days but he quickly realized the stress of maintaining that position was too much a hassle. He'd much rather live at his own pace doing what he loves: training, nurturing and bonding with his ground Pokémon while catching the occasional nap in the mud. He's still a powerful trainer though, as his status of E4 is a testament to.
Apart from the healthy benefits of mud he's also well protected from the heat of the sun as well as the irritating mosquitoes. He's always soaked in this mud, maintaining it each day through his daily mud wrestling routine with his Pokémon. He believes this makes their bonds stronger as well. It's also an excuse to just have fun.
Anonymous
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12206162 love the design, but I would like to see what the evo looks like with its eyes open, just for curiosity's sake
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12206193 that's awesome, I love this dude.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206136 i fucking love this guy! He's made of sunshine and happiness and mud!
Anonymous
Sketcher
Any thoughts, comments, and critique on the Solacari I drew last night? What do you want to see out of Solacari?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206226 I want it culled.
Sketcher
>>12206226 Note, I still need to fix the orange one as requested.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12206226 Is your TCGo working?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206226 We should cull solacari.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206234 I know Sketch, no worries here.
Anonymous
>>12206226 Absolute bottom right is fantastic
Quoted By:
>>12206225 >same name and trip on both posts >accused of samefag CAPTAIN OBVIOUS SAVES THE DAY AGAIN!
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12206225 yep
>>12206226 wings feel a little weird to me, perhaps have them extend off an individual appendage?
Anonymous
>>12206200 something like this
Sketcher
>>12206241 Yeah, I just got it working (because >mac). Took forever to set up but it works well now. Are you from the stream? I'll have to add you if so.
>>12206248 I can refine that one. I ran out of time last night, so I'll do that and
>>12206234 now.
>>12206252 Sure, I can try that.
Also are you ever going to come back? >>12206275 I like all three eyes.
Anonymous
>>12206226 They don't look like they would be able to fly at all. lrn2anatomy
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12206275 very nice, the solid ones look slightly better than the ones with the whites imo.
I would totally catch and train that beautiful motherfucker.
>>12206294 eh, I left to give clash space away from me, so it's up to him. Anonymous
>>12206296 And Tropius does?
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206294 I am. I have the please wait while the refresher is being updated thing though
Anonymous
>>12206296 Neither does Dragonite, Doduo, Charizard, Scyther, Delibird, Stunfisk, Hooth...
blondbomber
long time pokemon fag and art class drop out is here to draw!
Anonymous
ITT: Faggots still thinking we have a culling survey Have you noticed that the "Cull it" comments pick up on weekends and when school gets out? Really shows you how anxious the kids are to get to LE 4Chanz troleling.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206338 Draw what you please, pokemon homosexual
Anonymous
>>12206341 We do have a culling survey though. And the mons in question are not on it because one is approved and the other is being redesigned, so it's immune to probation, since Probation is designed to force people to put effort in getting things added in
Anonymous
>>12206338 redesign fire kobold please, it's the only thing keeping the line from confirmation.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
Tried graying up the bookshelf outlines and outlining the bed more in general, did it work?
Anonymous
>>12206338 Guys, try not to scare this one away.
Alright, there are no more submissions, but we redesign the ones that aren't approved. If something doesn't have a green arrow by it, look it up on the wiki and take a crack at it. Try to look for critique.
Anonymous
>>12206341 >implying I say "cull the bug waifu" every day.
Also we have a culling survey of sorts.
The probation idea is great though. Gives a nice little push to mons that are having trouble.
>>12206345 >And the mons in question are not on it because one is approved and the other is being redesigned Which ones?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
Approve bugwaifu
Anonymous
>>12206328 >>12206315 This is way different, we're talking about a bird here. I talking about how the wings would work.
Tomato !67YACB2E5k
Reposting steel kobold redesign, now with colors. Is this any better than my last redesign? With or without ears?
Anonymous
it's been a while but I'm back again with a new piece of music!
https://soundcloud.com/mudanaku/pixelated-number-9 Anonymous
Quoted By:
>people want to cull the bug waifu Pls no. I just want a bug pokemon that looks decent or cute.
Anonymous
>>12206361 The ones people spam "Cull it" over and over for. Solacari and the bug waifu
>>12206372 >implying Doduo isn't a bird A flightless one at that. But guess what, it can fly.
blondbomber
>>12206351 ok,I was gonna do the water stater but I could do fire first
>>12206359 since the last time I've seen the list alot more of the designs are over 66%
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206398 Without.
>>12206399 Stop... just stop that I had enough feels in one day.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206398 No ears. Loved the original redesign btw
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206399 Are all the newest tracks for the game?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206411 bug waifu is gonna be in probation. It's at 53%
Sketcher
>>12206296 >>12206309 >>12206248 This is what I have for him. Any better? Thoughts?
Also I hate colour schemes.
Anonymous
>>12206456 >Also I hate colour schemes. is it time for another Condessa/Magowl situation?
Sketcher
Quoted By:
>>12206461 That's why the the blank is there :3c Anonymous
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12206398 love both, if it cam down to a vote I'd have to say no ears, but that's because I love dino-kaiju
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206275 I preferred it with closed eyes.
Being based off of the largest living land mammal it seemed appropriate for it to have a kind of pompous look to it.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206398 Gender difference?
Anonymous
>>12206461 What if we take all versions and make into a part hard.gif? >>12206466 The majority.
We are maybe changing it now in the newest starter-survey.
deal with it Anonymous
im not happy with this... at all
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206411 >Implying Doduo has wings I'm talking about the anatomy here, not the capabilities it has
>>12206414 Please do the water starter
Anonymous
>>12206466 >>12206495 >>12206498 Who let the first one happen. It looks like a bipedal ice dog. At least the first one looks like an iguana.
But everyone knows this is BEST AGUANAUT
Sketcher
>>12206495 Oh, I forgot to release that. I still need to finish checking through some of the IPs, but at the moment muscular Aguanaut won by over 50% so it can go straight to confirmation survey.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206466 Anonymous did. He can be a force of good or a force of evil.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Re-proposing the idea of the post game island routes having remixed versions of official route themes.
Like how the Sevii Island routes had remixes of Gen 2's route themes.
I already did one of my favourite route themes.
https://soundcloud.com/dewdneym/pokemon-r-s-e-route-104 Even if we don't go through with this idea, this was good practice remixing anyway, i guess.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206496 yeah thats pretty terrible. also
>grolem >not fittslick Anonymous
>>12206509 >GF is running out of ideas!! a big fat starter thats half fighting, fucking gay, seriously anyone who like emboar is a faggot... i could design way better pokemon >hey guise look at this new aguanaut design! Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206414 No don't do any water starters please! we have a thousand fucking designs for it try something else
best one
>>12206509 Anonymous
>>12206529 You are so fucking underage it hurts.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12206529 so having a downs-syndrome aguanaut is better than having a vastly superior badass aguanaut because
>muh gamefreak mistakes Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206414 please do the fire starter final stage
Anonymous
>>12206534 >>12206545 personally im fine with the design and i like emboar
but you guys complained so much about how much you hate big bipedal muscle bound fighting starter, and now you love exactly that
Anonymous
>not wanting to cull Sombrerado What the fuck is wrong with you guys
Anonymous
>>12206559 /vp/ isn't a hivemind.
Anonymous
>>12206559 "you guys"
that being who exactly?
Anonymous
>>12206545 the current one is the gurthiest turd we've pushed out. Literally all forms were better.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206565 >wanting to cull one of the best mons in the dex >also its approved I bet you want to cull Doppole too.
Anonymous
>>12206559 >but you guys complained so much about how much you hate big bipedal muscle bound fighting starter When?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206565 obvious troll is obvious
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206509 The fact that you're vastly worse than the Feraligatr + Tornadus lovechild speaks volumes about how shit you are.
That was the best water starter period, ever. Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206538 still reading but it looks decent so far.
Anonymous
>>12206573 which aguanaut do you think I was defending?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206559 if its that or a retarded fat lizard then i'll pick the roid rager
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206565 >searching the dex image for the highest rated pokemon nuce rusin brah
Anonymous
>>12206559 No, we don't. Some guy in wifi or waifu general or two shitposters in a starter thread doesn't constiture /vp/'s opinion.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206581 i know. was just backing up your statement
Anonymous
>>12206566 >>12206568 >>12206590 the majority
or perhaps its just the people who are the loudest, either way its looking like its you
>>12206575 the second emboar was revealed
Anonymous
>>12206559 People hate Emboar more than they would otherwise just because he's the third consecutive fire/fighting. Then he's fat on top of that so it's an easy target. This water starter isn't fire/fighting and looks more buff than just fat.
Anonymous
>>12206559 I did not. Also, the body type is significatly different - Aguanaut is very bulky and broad, while Emboar is literally round.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206565 Is this some kind of gen /vp/ satire?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206599 We aren't reddit. Anyone can say what they want (within the rules).
Anonymous
>>12206604 >>12206607 alright, we can leave it to a majority rule
Anonymous
>>12206599 You really are an idiot are you? You actually believe that the people who complain about that shit are us, fuck I dont post on this autistic ass board outside of this already somewhat shitty thread.
Anonymous
>>12206628 And that is what will happen. In that way
nobody will be happy in the end.
Anonymous
>>12206629 Where are you from?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206637 well its gonna be close between the current 3
so 66% wont be happy as one will win with 34%
and then 17% of people will get there second choice at 51%
Anonymous
Anonymous
Obligatory dark and edgy room.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206559 I hate Embour because it's over designed, we had enough fire/fighting typed starters and it failed to live up to Tepig's potential.
None of those reasons apply to Aguanaut.
Anonymous
>>12205762 wow yes they have personality now
>>12205834 i think keeping the neck longish and making the legs a bit longer would be good. not as long as they were before but a little bit longer, perhaps just the front legs?
>>12206275 yeah what if the legs were a bit more like this
>picture related having longer front legs than back legs is a pretty defining characteristic of the basis animal
Anonymous
>>12206670 YES. Finally. Remember, only the first floor is accessible until you get Surf, so we should definitely put Carbite there.
Anonymous
i realize the leg thing is subtle but i think it helps
Gunvarrel !Oq/9NMk1yg
Started working on a Harpee backsprite. I'm having the hardest time shading the head and back. Any advice/people who want to take a shot at it?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206699 that's pretty good, mate
Anonymous
>>12206670 those fucking staris
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12206637 This is the last aguanaut we will have a confirmation survey on before summer. Its now, more than ever, that people realize that old designs arent happening, that they are never coming back, and to really think about this design for aguanaut. "Original was best, fuck this one" wont cut it anymore. You have to think long and hard if this aguanaut is gameready, or, better yet, is the base form game ready enough for me to be content with voting on minor aesthetical changes in a revision survey later?
People have started to realize all of this and youd be surprised how many people want us (the surveyors) to rig it in because of project progression sake. We arent because thats bullshit but they have a point. Legitimate dislikes and critiques are one thing. But this hostility, lack of empathy, and stubbornness because you like a few old designs is damn near goraurumfan levels. Burnings aguanaut and blues aguanaut are all dead. They were killed in the votes and surveys. After this we start from scratch again. Think long and hard when you people vote on this.
Anonymous
>>12206718 ill try, its really good btw
Anonymous
>>12206670 Tone down the black outlines. Make them somewhat duller and more grey, to fit the pokémon style.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12206714 What if the legs are spread out a bit more so they arent in front of the body so much as they are on the sides
Anonymous
.....i would vote to scrap aguanaut entirely. the fucking lizard isnt working out, literally no designs look good, and we could come up with something better in 3 days tops.
Gunvarrel !Oq/9NMk1yg
>>12206774 Thanks! Good luck, soldier.
Anonymous
>>12206763 Yeah, I agree. I mean, it could be pretty much the same situation as with the last new pokemon survey (yes, that one full of butthurt). In the sense that in the end, something will probably get through, but people will end up massively unhappy... And later let it go.
Well, except for poddlemoth. That poor creature will never be forgiven.
Anonymous
>>12206763 you're just saying that because you like the current aguanaut
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12205762 >>12206699 >>12206714 Keep doing what you're doing my good man. This will be another design that will look like it could be an actual Pokemon. Be proud of yourself.
As for Critique, maybe you could try to make the legs a little longer. They were as thick and tall as tree trunks.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206398 No ears, please. Also, I really missed this design in the last survey. It's the best.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206779 but muh bara scaliebait fighting marine iguana
Anonymous
>>12206456 The legs need to be placed further back.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12206779 No new submissions numbnuts. And you really want the summerkids to start submitting new designs? Do you want this to get made?
>>12206799 Id say it no matter which one was in the survey. I love burnings old aguanaut but frankly it didnt look water/fighting like this one does.
The point is stop holding a grudge
>>12206793 It will. 34% of people will lose probably, but if it is in they can always push redesigns. Which is how it fucking should be
Anonymous
>>12206787 ive never done backsprites before so not entirely sure how to do it
looking at the others they seem to have glare, but id have to add another color (i added one) and it makes him look to round
Anonymous
>>12206842 traffic doesnt increase that much over summer. Hell, maybe new summer kids could make better designs than what has been shitting out here. Either way aguanaut goes, a shit load of people are going to be unhappy with it and it wont ever get 66 percent. I would even doubt it getting 50 percent in the finalization survey.
Anonymous
>>12206700 I figured we could put Carbite in this room, like they did with Bagon in Meteor Falls.
>>12206759 The only ones we have unfortunately.
>>12206775 I didn't make the tiles.
Anonymous
>>12206853 added a bit of lighting, i cant seem to fit any more
im also rather impatiant
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206777 that might be something the original artist should attempt
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12206870 Because no one is willing to let it go. There are people who still want the totter line as water starters and those are never going to be the starters. No one moves on its horsehockey
Anonymous
>>12206891 if the last aguanaut doesnt get 50% in the finalization survey it would be a good thing to survey.
Anonymous
>>12206882 >>12206853 These are so great
I love you
Anonymous
>>12206872 So use the ones I just recolored to look less unnatural
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206714 Breat. Weird as it sounds I like it having big upper legs, and small lower legs/feet.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12206908 It already was. And it lost and will never be surveyed again
Sketcher
>>12206891 Orr it's because we haven't found the right design.
Dunky, Blue redrew Burning's design. That was surveyed a couple of times and it never had good results. If what you're saying is true, it should have topped the charts because it was so similar.
>>12206830 Oh, that's why it looks like it's about to fall over. Thanks, I'll try and fix that.
Also, here's what I hope the anon was looking for in terms of the Solacari fix. Also blanks of each type of wing for /vp/'s beautiful colouring skills.
Gunvarrel !Oq/9NMk1yg
>>12206872 Hmmmm, I think the darkest shade for the white feathers should be the color that was there do begin with. If you start using the colors from the black areas they start to blend in too much.
Anonymous
>>12206926 im talking about the one coming up. The "last one before summer" if it doesnt even get 50% of the vote for finalization, there should be a survey to scrap the idea and move on.
Anonymous
>>12206917 Post them, and I'll be more than happy to.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12206962 I just said no new submissions. We are stuck with aguanaut and flairees
>>12206929 >havent found the right design Describe the right design then
Also whats going on with those wings on solacari, they look way to rigid, like legos almost
Anonymous
where is the results for most recent starter survey?
Anonymous
>>12206910 thats so sweet
>>12206946 if i understand you correct, i did and just added a darker shade for shadow and used the normal white feather color for lighting
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12207001 Sketcher has em. Up to her if she posts them
Sketcher
>>12206990 If I knew, we would already have it. We clearly have not reached it yet unless this Aguanaut scores big in the confirmation survey.
They are solar rays.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206990 bow to the trip
Anonymous
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12207022 Not sure how I feel about the rays being so rigid, especially with them usually being waves and whatnot. What if that was incorporated into aesthetic design more?
Gunvarrel !Oq/9NMk1yg
>>12207014 Sorry, I worded that poor. What I meant to say it that you should probably only the original two shades. 2 shades is sort of the standard for a pokemon sprite. 3 is usually okay for Pokemon with shiny surfaces. 4 is just too many.
Sketcher
Quoted By:
>>12207055 >usually being waves That's light you are talking about. We perceive sun rays as solid beams. And wavy wings would be much, much odder than straight wings. I might be able to make the markings wavy, though, and I can try wavy feathers, but I predict it would look even less able to fly with the latter.
Anonymous
Doing redraws/redesigns. Any requests?
Anonymous
>>12207078 oh i see what you mean
in that case this is the best i can manage with 2
oh and this one
>>12206853 only has 3 but has 2 shades rather than 1 shade and 1 glare
Anonymous
>>12207145 check here
>>12205656 do any that you have the best ideas for
try to do what you can do best
Anonymous
>>12207145 Fire starter final stage!
Sketcher
Also, survey results.
http://www.mediafire.com/view/?n22r8x4x002isfs Congratulations to the new Aguanaut. All the rest need runoffs.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12207165 I would love to see our current designs in sprite form first. Sometimes that sells people
Anonymous
Gunvarrel !Oq/9NMk1yg
Quoted By:
>>12207152 Better, but I still think it would better with the 1 shade and what you call the glare. That's sort of how backsprites are set up. The majority of the sprite is in shadow, with sparse areas of light, usually either from the front or behind.
You can kinda see in the wing that was shaded initially. The lighting is coming from the front so the front part of the wing is the white "glare" while the rest of the wing is in shadow.
Anonymous
>>12207176 >new Aguanaut Finafuckingly. Just hope it will get trhough revision, or at least score something above 60.
Anonymous
>>12207180 Well I'm not satisfied with the one we currently have and would like to see it redrawn or redesigned. You can always sprite the current design afterwards.
Anonymous
I really hope you guys liked that shading on the bed, because I applied it to all the beds. Holy shit you guys we have so many beds.
Anonymous
>>12207164 whats the difference between the orange and white boxes?
Gunvarrel !Oq/9NMk1yg
>>12207176 >That split on Flairees Holy damn people really cannot agree on this guy.
Nice to see an design Aguanaut finally win out, though. C wasn't my first choice, but they were all pretty good.
Anonymous
>>12207226 uhm... i think orange means it only needs a bit of change
check the op image to see each mons approval
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207223 It's not perfect (there really should be some darker parts, to make it look less flat), but it's much, much better than it was before.
Anonymous
>>12207215 People still voted for the current middle stage though, we should hold off on a confirmation survey until it gets sorted out or it'll be a waste of time like when the Guinea Pigs were surveyed.
Sketcher
Quoted By:
>>12207226 Orange is just for surveyors telling us that a new design needs to be confirmed/deconfirmed. Green means official don't touch (in general). Empty means in need of a redesign.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206338 >art class drop out you disgust me
Anonymous
>>12207238 >>12207226 Orange means that the pokemon currently has a design that hasn't been surveyed yet and has a chance of being finalized, white means that there is no redesign and no chance of it currently getting in the game. Try to stick to redesigning the white ones.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207267 the only white ones are the troll, the starter, and the ibex
Nondell !PJ.OdWT5NU
>>12207145 Jaguile& Pounther
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207257 thats not what were talking about
>>12207267 is what we were talking about
Anonymous
>>12207295 what? that is one of the last things that needs redesigns, we have tons of non final mons
Anonymous
>>12207176 Flairees B is shit. Stop fucking voting him in.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12207222 Describe your aguanaut
>>12207229 What was your first choice?
>>12207250 Im working on this anon dont you worry weve forseen this being an issue so they wont be in the next confirmation survey
Nondell !PJ.OdWT5NU
Quoted By:
>>12207305 I meant for a redraw.
>>12207229 I know, damn.
A Flairees is best Flairees Anonymous
Before I go any further (cuz I know how harsh you motherfuckers are), how do these designs for the troll guy look
Anonymous
>>12207310 >baww stop liking what I don't like >buh buh muh objective opinions Even bad trolls found better material. Are you even trying?
Anonymous
>>12207357 Prevo looks like a rabbi.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207357 >>12207357 Pretty damn good so far, no one ever thoght to make more fluffly than thorny
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207383 You got a problem with Rabbis,
goyim ?
Anonymous
>>12207357 Make the evo look more like a hulking monstrosity.
Anonymous
>>12207321 I'm talking about Flairees, I never mentionned Aguanaut. Calm your tits.
Anonymous
Anonymous
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12207403 Describe your idel flairees then anon. Im curious is all
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207357 That prevo has some potential, but not that evo. try something else
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207176 Whew. Design A is winning by a hare for Flairees.
I have given up on the Aguanaut line completely, so I don't care, but I love that Flairees design.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207357 His shiny should be Shrek.
Anonymous
Just updated the Wiki with the new starter dex, still haven't changed the individual pokemon entries though. Being Clash is tuff.
Anonymous
>people want bug waifu culled Is there any reason other than being a waifu? Because that's the only reason I've seen for people wanting it culled.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12207482 Thats basically all Ive heard against it. Stop calling it the waifu and husbando and call it a poodle moth. Too many people afraid of boners, just redesign it sheesh.
Anonymous
Someone in the previous thread requested Sandra and Skink
Anonymous
>>12207519 Well theres also the contreversial entry survey.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12207535 I would love to see the painting of a blind skink
Anonymous
>>12207482 Essentially, no. We've had the discussion many times, and the gist seems to be:
>cull bugwaifu Why would you do that?
>it's a waifu What if we made it not a waifu?
>it being a waifu is integral to the design So basically you're saying is that referring to it as 'waifu' is more important to the community than having it exist?
>yes, we should cull it because it's a waifu That's stupid. We should just stop calling it that.
And so on
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12207539 You mean how there was no edit it? Do you remember the designs that didnt get in
Anonymous
>>12207535 those eyes what the fuck is up with the eyes.
Anonymous
>>12207554 So those same faggots must be spamming the votes or something if it's down to 53%.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207535 >Redheaded, pink-skinned Sandra instead of superior black-haired, olive-skinned Sandra. Disgusting.
Anonymous
>>12207456 The dex doesn't get changed because it needs runoffs.
First off, the Aguanaut C did win but needs runoffs to see which out of C won. Same goes with all of basically what was in that survey. Especially Flairees, designs need 50% to win. If there was more then 3 options and no design received over 50% then it will also go to runoffs between the top ones.
Please don't try changing the Dex with results that are not yet final.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207535 that's not sandra at all
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206981 bruh you replied to it
Anonymous
>>12207565 I noticed too, tried fixing it
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207570 Eh, a lot of people also want a 'redesign' in the sense of 'the same thing, but I can't justify this one because it has too many details and ornaments that make it look un-pokemannish." Yes, yes, they're not mentally separating the design from the art. Nothing new there.
Anonymous
>this started off great >the threads slowly devolved into shit >now everyone wants so-and-so fakemon culled for stupid reasons I'm scared. I just wanted to play a Pokemon game made by fans.
Anonymous
>>12207596 When was Sandra's skin and hair colour changed? Did I miss something, or is this artist just trying to hijack the design?
Anonymous
>>12207535 That would be me. Thank you mysterious redesignfriend, this art is beautiful.
Anonymous
>>12207608 it is always like this.
but it seems to go pretty well for a 4chan project.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207608 We'll get there. Hold steadfast Anon. We must persevere.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207628 I really hope it happens, because the only game 4chan has made so far is Katawa Shoujo. and that turned out worse than it should've been. Much worse.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207361 It's a shitty design that makes it look like a goat instead of a ram. Fuck off faggot.
Anonymous
>>12207618 Thought she was more an idea rather than being set in stone, didn't mean to step on anyone's toes. Did it as a request anyway
>>12207625 No problem, glad you like it
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12207582 Were treating that differently this time. Because there are so many edits, it will take forever for us to narrow one down. So its add edits as redesigns and then for confirmation you vote on the base design. This way, votes arent diluted by minor edits
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207608 There are plenty. This one has encountered so many hurdles because it's an exercise in true community collaboration. The tidal wave of creative forces means that these designs blow every other fakédex out of the water.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
Been away a while. Here's an old ass Coal Mine floor 1 I made, if we don't have one finalized yet
Sketcher
>>12207666 No actually, I'm doing the edit thing in this survey. It shouldn't take very long and will be wrapped up in this one, or the next because of the way I'm handling it.
It's up to Clash's discretion on if he wants to put Aguanaut up now or later. It doesn't really matter either way.
Anonymous
>>12207596 is that some freakin plan of yours ? You are making super arts of that mud bastard and shit design for Sandra. You stinky manipulator!
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207596 damn! She's not a painter! God.
Anonymous
>>12207687 Mudbro is better anyway
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207666 But the dex shouldn't be updated when there isn't one specific design that won. You can survey them however but if we change everything with a certain design that is a bit biased being that everyone will now always see that one when they look at the dex/wiki. I can remove all designs from the Aguanaut box till it is decided.
>>12207686 See it doesn't take too long to decide if we start having surveys immediately with it.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206670 that actually looks pretty cool. I like the layout.
Here's more fitting stairs for your tileset
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207653 Newsflash: if you change a character's physical appearance completely, it's not really the same character anymore.
But you already knew that, you just didn't care.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207701 1/10 obvious troll
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12207686 After my what dont you like about it survey.
Anonymous
>>12207687 Maybe he's not brilliant at drawing people. Mud to is basically a blob of a man covered with mud and a bit of clothing, he's not difficult to draw
>>12207701 >opinions What about the one-armed mountaineer concept?
Sketcher
Quoted By:
>>12207742 No, now. That way you can do it on what the group decided on.
Anonymous
>>12207748 this guy's right, I'm rather awful at people. The painter part is my mistake though, thought she was a general artist, not exclusively a maker of sand castles.
Anonymous
Hey Sketcher. Just PM'ed you the link to a larger version of the Agunaut C design spread. Only for voting on tiny details like the mouth and what not.
Anonymous
>>12207766 Its o.k.
wanna make out?
Anonymous
>>12207783 You'd have to guide me
Sketcher
Quoted By:
>>12207769 Thanks, I'll grab that. I have a smaller version but the larger will help out more.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207788 This gif gives you all the info you need, dubsman/dubswoman
Anonymous
>that one mon only you like
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207836 But you're wrong
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206779 Me too. But it's far too late for that, and the people on this project would rather sacrifice quality than break one of their rules.
I know things like deadlines are needed to keep the project going, but the starters are THE most important mind in the dex. There's never an excuse to fix something that isn't working when it's a starter.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207554 >That's stupid. We should just stop calling it that. Well you guys shouldn't have called it that on the first place
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207836 Hiloquins cool but that pose sucks
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206990 so now you have authority?
Anonymous
We should cull the poodle moth
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207836 I love Brolequin
I seriously do not get why everyone hates it
Anonymous
>implying owls aren't excavators
Anonymous
Howlequin was hands-down the most fun of the playing cards to make. I think eh's a pretty cool guy.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208000 Eh kills torlls and doesn't afraid of anything
Anonymous
>>12208000 I hope he gets an evo in Gen 2.
Anonymous
Anonymous
what animal is turkistador based on?
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12208073 The early versions are hoppoes and the evo is a turkey
Anonymous
FINAL FINAL PROBATION SURVEY (please) Anonymous Sat 04 May 2013 21:47:13 No. 12208083 Report >>12208025 http://www.surv eymonkey.com/ s/WTSVR98
I come bearing gifts. 56% is required for a line to be voted onto probation. See the newest survey for my proposal on dealing with the Artifish Dilemna.
I'm going to address a few issues in the comments below.
>Cull solacari. >For the doppole situation, make it possible to drop single parts of a line, so in that case Artifish could be dropped, leaving Doppole as a stand-alone to be probated or approved on its own. >If a liked evo can't find a worthy prevo, or vice-versa, it shouldn't be kept. Working it in as a no-evo mon would squeeze in an otherwise unnecessary dex entry. This is addressed by the case-by-case approach I suggest in the survey. Basically, we when this issue comes up, we'll survey and find out if people think the design can be reworked as a standalone or should be dropped along with its line.
>Survey each pokemon in a line separately. The logistics of this are very complicated (the limit is based on lines and putting only one Pokemon on probation causes problems if it then gets dropped at the end). It is much better to deal in lines and be careful about spotting where one stage is dragging the line down.
>Since there will only be 3 lines on probation.. When a line gets put up, do a survey where C&C can be given to each of the stages alone. If all but one reach 66%, and the one that doesn't add up.. Keep if it looks like a valid line or single-stage pokemon Remove if it's the final stage that's below 66%, or if the flow of the line is too messed up. (this can be decided in a follow-up survey) Gunvarrel !Oq/9NMk1yg
Quoted By:
>>12207982 Oh my god I'm going to pee myself.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208080 I do believe initial inspiration for final evo was actually not a turkey, but don't quote me on that.
>>12208025 Howleking get
Anonymous
>>12208083 >people have mentioned placing the least liked ones on probation first, i think this is a bad way to look at it. the "least liked" are the ones that require the most work from artists to get it to 66 percent, while the ones that are nearly finalized could be finalized easily... just make sure that you explain that putting something on probation does not mean you dont like it, it means you think its almost game ready Actually, probation is designed to push designs that aren't being worked on and are being neglected. Designs nearly approved do not need probation to get over 66% approval. Designs that haven't been worked on in weeks need the push.
>pokemon should be polled independently not as lines. this much seems obvious. >Make sure that revision surveys happen at least once a week, and that confirmation surveys happen once every two weeks. Even if only two lines get revised. If this fails to happen, I think it the probation fails to meet its goal. There should be a processes to make sure that each pokemon gets a fair chance, even if finals get in the way for a surveyor. Also, after a pokemon's probation period is over, if it has gotten an approved redesign, it should be removed from probation, but still be eligible for its confirmation survey. This is obvious, but I haven't seen anything saying it. >God, i hate you so much for this. >Get on with it already. >Probation percentage includes the "Almost perfect but needs a colour change" option as well as the "perfect" option. That means that the large majority of people love the design, or thinks it needs a slight change. It would be stupid to drop something with that high of an approval and only needs a slight tweak or two. >There should be a survey for each line put on probation straight away. It will ask for input on changes and can also deal with the potential like for one mon and dislike for the evo or whatever. It will also help the artists by consolidating any ideas in one space. Anonymous
>>12208105 QUESTION
I'm assuming that the starters and legends are exempt from probation? We can't lose them and carry on.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12208083 >artfish dilema >not god tier pun "dopple effect" Anonymous
>>12208083 >56% I know this isn't how we interpret survey results, but... seriously? You OBVIOUSLY have a "58% group" and a "56% group" and they're of very roughly equal size. And they're all happier with 57% than the other group's preference.
The way to /maximise satisfaction/ is 57%. Again, that's not what we're doing, but it kind of feels weird when the results are this clear.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208136 This goes without saying.
Anonymous
>>12208147 Look at the average rankings. More people are pleased by 56 than by 57%
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12208145 It's not an effect though.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Have you submitted your names for the turtles, rod dragons, and quecko evo to the wiki or forum names hread yet? There will be no submission survey like before, you must submit your names this time to the wiki/forum for them to be counted
Anonymous
>>12208147 >>12208159 You know, if that is serious, it is better than Chim/Cholio survey.
Anonymous
>>12208145 >>12208175 its a pun off of the doppler effect
the dopple effect-
the change in love of a pokemon for an observer relative to its evo
>>12208147 thats because alot wanted as more than 58, alot wanted less than 56, more wanted less
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12208195 When will Lightbulb 1 get a name? Didn't Neureka win last round?
Anonymous
>>12208199 I get the pun. But it isn't an 'effect'.
But hey, semantics.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12208218 It did win. The wiki hasnt been updated apparently. All of hatracks name surveys are final
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12208219 Your jerk levels are coming up on my doppoler radar
Anonymous
>>12208159 I did so. That's why I'm not contesting the result, just the method of interpretation. It's clear that basically everyone either ranked the three "58-57-56" or "56-57-58," with 4 or so more in the latter group. I'm just really uncomfortable with a democratic process that can reach a conclusion like that, not with the conclusion itself. I mean, I can't argue that the difference between 56% and 58% is significant and that the difference between 42% and 47% is not significant. That would be moronic.
But... I dunno, man, it seems weird to say "well, the group who chose the other ordering was slightly smaller, sucks to be them." It makes having the middle option completely pointless.
I don't think this is explicable in any sane amount of text, so I'm gonna stop here and avoid arguing.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208231 Nice. I'll update the wiki.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208231 When are we gonna have another name survey?
Anonymous
>>12208239 Hey, survey maker here. I actually agree with your point but going by the average has always been the way. In the interest of not running another survey, I decided it was best just to take the highest average. It's only a percentage point difference after all and this way, the process is internally consistent.
Sketcher
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206086 we really need those slate colored stairs.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206670 drawbridges need a better tileset too. maybe make them darker. maybe add a couple tiles with holes?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206718 shoulders up and in. maybe continue ruffle behind his head
Anonymous
>>12206779 we have no better water 3-stager. at least with areis line if it isn't ready we can swap in ignishell
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208274 Agreed. The alternative in cases like this is a more mathematical approach (a weighted average), but the result is that everyone has to vote 100% or 0%. It's not very pleasant, really, because it means lying about your preferences and... okay let's leave the ethics of democracy for /pol/ to figure out.
I'm pretty sure that's what /pol/ does.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12207596 since we are doing overworlds to some degree. which move animation should substitute balling in our lead/free-roming poke? later end of dig? early piece of acrobatic?
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12208387 Hahahahhahahahhahahahahhahahahahhahaa no. They lost with the totter line. They too had their week in the sun and they blew it
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208479 OH SHIT ITS HAPPENING!
Worldwibe !!Ss4pOUddSQJ
I need some opinions on colours on what I'm working on the stream with
Worldwibe !!Ss4pOUddSQJ
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12208479 OH GOD I WANT THEM BUT MUDDY BLOBBY
Anonymous
>>12208281 Come on /vp/, don't let A's Fumigas win!, it's so cliched for a ghost Pokemon...
It's going 1.62 to 1.92, anything can happen!
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12206466 Yeah seriously, it's fucking terrible.
Anonymous
>>12208281 GODMOTHAFUCKINGDAMNITSKETCHER!
every time you or dex posts one of these we say:
post the image so we can make sure you dont make any giant error and so you can clarify anything thats confusing
im getting real sick of this shit
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208281 >D Thoraxe is winning lolwut
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208479 she is so great
Anonymous
>>12208574 this. And that atom evo ... another flying head. Seriously /vp/ ?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208281 sketcher seriously
>>12208627 this
its screwing with our votes when you put kobold steel as "rock kobold"
Anonymous
>>12208666 I hate the idea of just giving up on pokemon and culling them, but if there really were pokemon I'd cull it'd be the atoms. All their designs are just floating balls, that's the problem with them and it's never going to be anymore than that.
Anonymous
>>12208689 What's so damn terrible about floating balls?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208479 I love her so much
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208083 LATEST PROBATION THEMED SURVEY HERE
DURRtle !!SUDJMflPZTZ
I maed diznoseless for you
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208281 Sketcher please post the image before doing the survey.
This design is missing for the steel kobold.
>>12206398 Anonymous
>>12208768 oh, wow, thats actually good
could you make the white fur go down further on the evo? make it cover its crotch a bit?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208733 Voltorb syndrome
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12208768 hey this is great, it's really different than what we have now. Great job.
Anonymous
>>12208479 Ah, raven-haired, olive-skinned Sandra, just like she's supposed to be. All is well again.
Seriously, she's my favorite Gym Leader/E4 design in this project. With the gay lifeguard on second place.
Anonymous
>>12208826 Doppole's face is hilarious
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208826 This is an awesome picture.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12208768 Dat tail
It takes forever but people finally have their tailed troll
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208842 Heh, I hadn't even seen it hiding there until you pointed it out.
DURRtle !!SUDJMflPZTZ
>>12208794 >whats sarcasm >>12208796 thats what I tried
>>12208783 tried something else too
Anonymous
>>12208768 FINALLY a troll design that doesn't make me throw up a little when I see it.
>thread 404s earlier >okay i'll just wait in the catalog until it comes back up >search for "/vp/" >nothing >nothing all day >find this thread just now >"/vp Makes a Game General" >/vp Fuck you guys.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208903 Nice blogging m8
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12208903 >not looking based on the image Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208526 That, sir, is a poor substitute for delicious Sandra.
Anonymous
Snogre's shiny needs to resemble Shrek
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208479 This is fantastic.
I don't think anyone can "de-throne" her now.
Anonymous
>>12208526 You gotta love a happy simple laid back character who isn't involved in an inane love triangle.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208903 fuck us because you dont know how to use 4chans catalog function?
and if theres no thread just make one
>>12208954 enough references, not everyone should have theyre favorite le meme in the game
Sketcher
Ok, some of the comments on the survey are commenting on the legs of my Solacari. Is it because of the coloured blobs? Those are the rings around the legs, as seen on the current version. Does that make a difference or no?
Anonymous
>>12208985 It's not the rings, it's the legs themselves. Too straight and wide.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208985 >Criticism doesn't count if it's my design Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208975 Don't blame all the Sandra fans for that crap. I've personally always maintained that there's NOTHING like that between Sandra and Sean, nor has it ever been. They're just friends.
Also, I hope there won't be too much backstory drama between any of the characters, really. Some is fine, like stating that they're friends or something. Making a big deal out of it is just dumb.
Anonymous
>tfw when you love muddy buddy but sandra is the perfect ground e4 member
Anonymous
Sketcher
Quoted By:
>>12209014 Oh, ok. I was basing it off of Moose's bird legs. I guess I just don't execute it in the same way, then.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208985 Sketcher, could you please stop trying to sabotage this project?
Oh, and I agree with the others, please get your head out of your ass for once in your life and read this:
>>12208627 Anonymous
Gauge ball- "gauges health to decide catch chance more so than other balls" with normal pokeballs it ranges from lets say 20% catch chance at full hp and 60% at barely any hp with the gauge ball it ranges from lets say 1% to 90%, so if you get a mon down to almost 0 hp its as good as an ultra ball, but at full hp its worse than a normal ball opinions?
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
Sketcher
>>12208627 I do. No one commented period except for cull solacari/bug waifu and an atom design. However right now is also a really busy time, so it was either now or next week. Lots of little surveys are better than one survey every two weeks.
What mistakes do I have in this one? If you say "you are missing a fuckton of designs", refer to both the blurb at the beginning of the survey and what I say above. I got the survey checked by other surveyors, so thats the only thing you can really say.
Anonymous
>>12209074 Why wouldn't I just use an Ultra ball?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209076 They're not mutually exclusive...
There's always my "boss trainer at the end of every route" idea...
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209086 >calling steel kobold rock >using ratings when weve voted against it >surveying designs that are already being surveyed but mostly its for incase you fuck up big
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12209037 Muddy buddy for the second member of your magnificent seven
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209086 "Rock Kobold"
And this project has enough problems as it is, we really don't need you to make things worse like you usually do.
Anonymous
>>12209099 well there is the possibility of making it better than ultraball at 1%hp, but that could be to good with endevour
but great balls are used for the same reason, you dont just get 649 ultra balls when you start the game
Anonymous
>>12209037 Now, I'm new to these threads, but couldn't you just reuse the one that doesn't make it into the E4 for a Battle Frontier style thing? Or challenges spread through the game like the Battle Tents?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209037 Feels very redundant to have both a Ground Gym and a Ground E4 member, though.
Anonymous
>>12209131 .... Or unique trainers at the ends of routes?
Anonymous
>>12209131 >>12209153 yeah we can reuse concepts but some dont work with their character concept
so it would just be some muddy guy rather than an important character
Anonymous
>>12209159 Shame about him not being an important character, but maybe we can work him in to a plot point or something.
captcha: pubjail herself
Anonymous
>>12209153 ShinyGold did this and it was terrible. They all felt like they were added as an afterthought rather than actually being planned.
Anonymous
>>12209169 we have alot of concepts for side plots, (its possible that will happen with the poison mask girl), so it will have to be really supported
who knows what will happen, its pretty open ended but i have to agree with
>>12209185 Anonymous
>>12209099 I think this question is so good we should seriously consider removing ultra balls entirely, or at least making them unavailable in shops.
There are lots of cool alt-balls that are outclassed entirely by the UB's flexibility and strength. Removing them might add something to the game.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209169 whos to say we won't have additional challenges and so forth. people are so hard on the side story, 8 gyms, 4 elite . 1 champ. some people prefer fighting gyms, so making temples, minigym-like areas, and so forth for later progression no reason we can't add them. maybe they give keys like muddy key, to open up further floors on a challenge tower.
Anonymous
>>12209185 They don't have to necessarily all be special characters with their own sprites..
Just have a trainer 3-5 levels higher than the normal ones at the end.
Anonymous
looking for pokemon battles FC 2581 3626 7263 name Tay
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209287 wrong thread man
Nondell !PJ.OdWT5NU
Quoted By:
>>12209287 Wifi general is what you're looking for, with that said I could battle you in a few hours.
Anonymous
>>12209226 The problem isn't with them being unique characters; it's that they felt pointless given that Pokemon already had plenty of "boss" battles in the form of Gym Leaders, rival battles, and so on.
Anonymous
can u point me to the right thread
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12208882 looks pretty cool yo, would love to see this in a fight with monkenzuma
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209329 I just wanna spice up the routes a bit. They're always so bland compared to the rest of the game.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12209200 There was once an idea, a plot put forward that brought the idea of a large evil team that was of a grandiose size. This plot had a very large organization with tons of grunts. Too many grunts, in fact for one person to fight. For you to take this team down, youd need a group of trainers, those dedicated to fight this evil team. Alone, hundreds of grunts would overwhelm the player. This team, a group of individuals, 12 suggested at first, would team up with you to stop this team. These trainers would be unique, reoccurring, and all very interesting. With mapfriend doing NPC surveys again, I bring back this idea now that we have some ideas that could fill this role. Imagine muddy buddy riding in on terrorcotta while calcifer fortunei shuttles mask girl and tired bro into battle in his chariot of mystery
Thoughts?
>inb4 gay Anonymous
>>12209341 I would love to see a good monkenzuma...
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12209356 THIS
All of my want.
And we could have some pretty sick double battles...
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209357 >good >monkenzuma You have to choose one, they're mutually exclusive.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
Random thought. "fortune" sounds like 4chan Can we use that somewhere? Not saying it needs to be the villainous team but might be nice to hide in plain sight somewhere, kinda like viipii.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209335 im assuming you tried to reply to me
also im assuming your rather new
but go here
>>12204144 Anonymous
>>12209373 Double battles with an NPC ally are really annoying, though.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209392 but not if he's muddy!
Anonymous
>>12209037 >>12209076 competing since forever
Anonymous
>>12209407 So I have a question.
Is there some reason we can't have Sandra and Muddy as a double battle in the E4?
Did we vote on that or something, cause I don't remember it.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12209373 >>12209394 Best part, for different experiences the trainers are recruited with sidequests, similar to the trainers for double battles in d/p/pt. How many grunts you face is entirely dependent on how much work you put into the game.
Anonymous
I know fixing finalized is like the last thing we need to do right now, but planting a seed. Right now Cahokisect is all day-of-the-dead and Mortasque is a scary face. What if instead Mortasque had the DOTD theme and Cahokisect was egyptian themed. Fits him better being all scaraby and jewel incruseted. Don't see why he needs to be a fancy skull in the first place.
Anonymous
>>12209419 then it would be the elite 5 and they arnt similar or work as a pair at all
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209037 Newfag here.
Who is this Sandra and how can she be better than Muddy Buddy?
Anonymous
>>12209356 I like the idea of having more recurring characters, but I think the reason for them is kinda lame. Having everything that isn't the Gym Leader Challenge revolve around the big bad evil team has always been a weakness with Pokemon games, in my opinion.
Anonymous
>>12209451 I know they aren't similar in character, but they could be, like, rivals that compete for that spot but can't ever determine a winner.
Just trying to please everyone.
Silly me...
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12209453 We shall see what the surveys decide
Anonymous
>62% Requesting helpful thoughts or comments how to improve this guy. Keeping in mind he doesn't need a drastic re haul, just a tuneup.
Anonymous
>>12209341 I'd draw such a thing, but like all my fanart ideas for this, I'm holding off until designs are finalised.
Anonymous
>>12209481 Slim it up and make it look muscular-ish.
Look to the legendary beast trio for reference.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209356 nice double battle bros. plus the double battle bros you can duel, and would become the gym leaders, elite in our gen 2. we just need to give a reason for them all to be your co-op buddy at some point
Anonymous
>>12209481 Actually maybe this dude is more important for short term goals.
Anonymous
>>12209470 Try to please everyone, and you'll just end up pleasing nobody.
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12209488 fair enough, I can see why. although, you could also make your own redesigns into that fanart you make, like that one guy did with the rainbow serpent prevos.
Anonymous
DURRtle !!SUDJMflPZTZ
>>12209481 make him look less like an animal
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209481 Try giving it less of an aladin art style, and more poke/sugi style
Anonymous
>>12209481 >fix the feet >make him not so fat/ugly >fix the face Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12208689 At least we can try to make them cool floating balls.
Anonymous
>>12209438 Mortasque isn't just a random scary face, it's based on the Death's Head Moth.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death%27s-head_Hawkmoth Anonymous
>>12209580 Are people so autistic and underage that a pokemon being 'fat' is a huge negative for them
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208893 hey turkeyfriend
Anonymous
>>12209481 make it bipedal
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209481 Remove the golden orbs from its ankles. It looks strange.
Anonymous
>>12209622 no its not that, its just that it seems like it cant even move, even the fat GF mons look like they could actually manage to walk around
ankleosaurois (whatever) is a good example of good fat
Anonymous
>>12209610 I Like this. Color it
Anonymous
>>12209407 Turkistador is tiny.
Anonymous
>>12209648 Jesus christ don't listen to any these people, this how get the shitty designs we have now.
>>12209664 Are you Blind of course it can move! Have ever even seen a fucking boar
Anonymous
>>12209648 give it a big ol' monkey dick amirite Anonymous
>>12209580 >>12209568 >>12209491 Better feedback then usual. But any suggestions on HOW to fix the feet/face etc?
Like what you would prefer them to look like?
And does anyone else see a conflict in making a pig less fat and more muscular?
Just something to chew on while I try sketching.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209680 More like a big ol' boar dick Anonymous
>>12209673 He is? Aren't turkeys huge?
Anonymous
>>12209710 In that pic he is.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209697 >And does anyone else see a conflict in making a pig less fat and more muscular? I do, those are guys are idiots.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209710 turkeys are usually around 3ft in height and full grown toms weigh anywhere from 21lbs at the smallest to 30lbs at the biggest
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209697 Again, look at the three legendary beasts as reference.
That's what this guy reminds me of, but right now he's goofy.
Keep him thick though, more like Entei.
Anonymous
>>12209679 i just mean it looks to stubby, it seem awkward (yeah thats a better way to describe it)
>>12209697 muscular is not the idea, it just needs to be less awkward, like barely longer or something
as for face/feet
the gold and scrunched hands look silly, maybe making them bigger could work? maybe?
and the face needs to be different but not sure how
Anonymous
heights arnt decided thats just what the artist pictured dont worry about it, itll be decided later
Anonymous
>>12209580 >"I only like the pokemon I want to have sex with"
Anonymous
>>12209752 >and the face needs to be different but not sure how Agreed. I think more 'cosmic' and less 'a pig.' But I'm not sure what would accomplish that exactly.
Anonymous
>>12209723 was probably a mirage under the hot sun
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209769 i corrected myself later
i should have said to make him less awkward
it just seems like i could knock him over with a flick
he doesnt look balanced
Anonymous
>>12209770 >the pig should look less like a pig Anonymous
>>12209779 he's still fucking tiny in that pic
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209779 The funny thing is that's the exxact same size i imagine Turkistador to be.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209793 you mean
>the pokemon should look less like a pig >>12209797 this \/
>>12209766 Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12209853 What the fuck, man. He's so small I can barely see him.
Anonymous
>>12209853 >>12209875 not that i dont like a good back and forth of posting funny images
could you try doing a redesign or something
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208768 That's... actually pretty cool
Anonymous
>>12209875 Dude, any bigger and he'll have stuff orbiting him
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209884 I'll have a go at the spiders tomorrow
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209890 >>12209890 He's fucking tiny m8. Stop using a microscope.
Anonymous
Dex Survey !c3FtBquQFA
New confirmation Survey Dex Survey !c3FtBquQFA Sun 05 May 2013 00:45:36 No. 12209944 Report https://www.surveymon key.com/s/Confirmation4 9 this time. Please enjoy. Everything else is either in the redesign survey or will soon be.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
I was thinking we should make Boarealis a gimmick Pokemon, so I came up with a new move and ability for him on the forum (section: new moves and abilities). Here they are: For the space theme, it could reference wormholes, a concept oddly not already taken by Gamefreak: -Wormhole: Cuts Defense and Special Defense and Half and doubles Special Attack and Speed It could also have an ability referencing the electromagnetic radiation which creates Aurora Borealis: -Electromagnet: When hit by an electric move, it gains a resistance to both Steel and Electric types
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209927 we should cull the bug waifu
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209927 think he'd be fine if stuff was toned a bit down, at least the feathers on his head/neck. Too many small details for a sprite. Colours are boring, but still fine
Anonymous
Scary poison girl and muddy buddy also fire priestess and her grandpa for postgame content?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209944 it makes me so happy when these surveys are posted!
there are some really good ones in there and its nice to see the dex getting more complete
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12210084 Or at some point people wronged by the evil team who join up to help you. Like moth girl and fire priest help defend grass waifu and the team tries to torch the jungle to flush grass spirit out
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12210217 How hard would that sort of thing be to program?
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12210238 not sure, i imagine you could edit the formula for catch rate but i dont know how it works
can we get a programmer to shed some light on the subject?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210262 Uh...I'm not exactly a scripter myself, but I'm pretty sure it's doable. Just have to set perimeters for the ball or something.
We need to find someone who really knows how to code from scratch.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12210217 If we're doing custom balls,
Curve Ball
Catch rate increases the more health (percentage wise) the target Pokemon has over the one you're fielding. So if your Pokemon is in the red and you try and catch something at full health with a curve ball, the odds are stacked in your favour.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210345 >>12209127 and >>12209208 that question is retarded
by that logic the game should only have masterballs
Anonymous
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12210393 neat, good work so far, wonder how it will look colored
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12210376 thats been discussed heavily
i personally didnt like it much, it kinda breaks the point of pokeballs, and honestly i think its way to easy to catch mons in the real game
>>12210393 i like it
>>12210411 the top one is great
the bottom isnt
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12210411 I hated the old design. Nothing made it pokemony. This one, this has character to it
Anonymous
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12210411 pretty cool moose, love the dynamic poses
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
>>12210444 >>12210428 Hue. The bottom one isnt very good. I'll try some more poses after. Hemming this stupid coat is giving me nightmares. There's too many edges.
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12210456 if the coat is too edgy take it to teen counselling
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12210456 yeah its just that it looks like he gets wider at that part, and i think it works better if he cant "stand" like that
Anonymous
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
Quoted By:
>>12210481 Hmm. I might just try that.
Anonymous
>>12210428 >breaks the point of pokeballs Maybe just bind it to the health of your Pokemon? So if your Poke is in the red, it is 3x as effective. 2x if you're in the yellow and 1x if you're healthy. This is on top of the regular bonus from the enemy being weaker. That way, it is more useful than ultra but riskier. Hence, curve ball.
Anonymous
>>12210411 First one is very dawwww.
But I never liked the long tongue. Dude's not a snake,.
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
>>12210497 I didn't really like the 'standing'. The official one is sort of 'sitting' like that though.
>>12210510 It's a mexicam mole lizard~ But it had the tongue so I thought id add it.
Anonymous
>>12210505 the thing is you could just walk around with almost dead pokemon and use curve balls
>>12210515 yeah i guess, but the way the body is proportioned it looks more like its his neck thats stood up rather than his entire upper half
Anonymous
Spriter here, sorry about not working the last couple days. Just checking in to say I'm not dead, just busy preparing for the upcoming anime con(Acen), haven't had time to peacefully work on my stuff because of school and should probably get it done because the con is in two weeks.
>>12205842 Don't even think about TOUCHING that prevo, it is almost the cutest mon in our dex.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210552 Yes? Same way I can walk around at night and use dusk balls.
Anonymous
>>12210563 well i dont know who you are, but if you need something to sprite check
>>12205656 Anonymous
>>12205670 >other ideas: random grass types are half poison?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210552 An 'exploit' that involves you walking around with a weak mon at the head of your party seems fine to me. Remember, if the ball does fail then you basically ensure that your mon will faint.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210581 My most recent work was adding backsprites to Berratel and the chameleons (third one is in progress but looks kinda bad). I likely won't have time tonight but I'll definitely look at picking one of those next.
Anonymous
Some small edits to these songs.
https://soundcloud.com/dewdneym/pokemon-r-s-e-route-104-1 https://soundcloud.com/dewdneym/youngster-jose-wants-to-6 I have the idea of a route theme in my head, but i think its time i finally get to those moth sisters.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210765 hm. i just realized the guitar at the end of the subway one is way too loud
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12208281 Thank you for not voting for the shitpost designs for Thoraxe. Those HAVE to have been jokes.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>skipping questions in confirmation survey
Anonymous
>>12210619 >random You mean all mono-grasses right?
This is unrelated, but can anybody give me one legit reason why Bulbasaur is Poison?
Anonymous
>>12210919 Because Gen I sucks.
Anonymous
>>12210919 Because pollution.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210910 i skipped the bugs because i have no clue about them and would just be a shit vote
its better that people who are uneducated on a specific subject leave voting to those who know what they are voting on
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210411 the first one is fine but second one is too humanoid
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12207357 New evo design instead of the skinny one. I can do more sketches if needed.
Anonymous
>>12210930 >>12210952 >>12210990 So no real reason, just a Masuda mistake
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210919 If I had to guess I'd say so it wasn't DOA in viridian forest.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12211051 Not necessarily a mistake.
Just a strange Gen 1-ism.
Anonymous
>>12211048 I like the angrier eyes on the left, but the bigger nose on the right.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12211105 It kinda looks like a frog. On don't like the hands being on the ground.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12210499 This is great. I love the symmetry
Anonymous
>>12211051 Yep. A mistake that confused a generation into thinking that grass was weak to psychic.
Anonymous
>>12211139 Anything regarding psychic in gen 1 is a legitimate gamefreak mistake.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12211191 >Lick and Night Shade Why, Game Freak, why?
Anonymous
We should cull the wimpy one in the back.
Chen !!nlrLrc/pgY6
Quoted By:
>>12205656 So does anyone have that small collection of Sequoia's colors? We should at least knock her out.
Chen !!nlrLrc/pgY6
Quoted By:
>>12211285 Quality bro plz
I love em and I'm sure Clash would too. Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12211373 But there's 7 colors of the rainbow.
And there's no Solacari on that pic. Anonymous
Anonymous
>No one likes Beat >No artist can save him >mfw he'll lose in the Steel, Electric, and obviously ground position
DURRtle !!SUDJMflPZTZ
Quoted By:
>>12211440 keep the original eyes
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12211139 You think that's bad? Every ghost pokemon was weakened to psychic.
Why couldn't they have been mono ghost?
Anonymous
>>12211440 lookin' good.
Im liking the extra tusks.
Though, id prefer it fat Anonymous
>>12211440 Space pig's looking good now that his legs appear sturdier! I like the gold version.
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
Quoted By:
>>12211440 I like the gold one~ The double tusks are pretty cool, too. When SZ is ready to sugi him, may I offer to do his mane again? (So SZ gives me the sugi but with a blank mane)
Anonymous
Chen !!nlrLrc/pgY6
Quoted By:
>>12211446 I like him but he could really use some better art from what's been given so far. Maybe something with a heavy 90's DJ esq appearance with a wild look similar to Roxie that says fuck you buddy, you came into the wrong gym. It doesn't have to try too hard but it could be enough to get the point. Sketcher
Quoted By:
>>12211440 Gold is best pig.
Anonymous
>>12211474 I thought silver seemed more 'spacey' and there seems to be a lot of gold theme already in the game.
Also, as you can see I kinda suck at shading gold.
>>12211464 You're right, I should have never caved to peer pressure.
>>12211474 I think those colors are beautiful and I failed so hard to make them from scratch. If you're the one that did the original you should by all means do the new mane.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12211547 *if people like the gold then by all means go gold.
Or even better, get someone else to competently draw the gold in there.
Anonymous
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
>>12211547 I think you misquoted, but yes, I drew the original one and his spacey mane~ It was actually intended to be fanart since I loved the idea, but it took off from there.
It took like 3 minutes to do his mane. It's all about opacity, baby.
Sketcher
Quoted By:
>>12211547 I find the gold contrasts more with the body, which is why it looks arguably better. Silver is very nice, but not for defining parts of the body.
Anonymous
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
>>12211610 Are you using a tablet? I used many different sized, but I also have a tablet which adjusts size/opacity based on pressure. Most of that is using a broad stoke, whereas yours are choppy , thin, and very opaque.
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
heeeey guuuuys I'm goona make a wallpaper toniiiight I hate eeeeeverything right now
Anonymous
Quoted By:
Spitballin here
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
>>12211610 It seems that it was all done on the same layer. It was also probably locked, since I can't into masks.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12211629 Yeah, but I wasn't using opacity sensitivity. Because reasons.
Anyway, I feel like we made strides with piggy, any chance people have suggestions for hatty?
>>12209518 Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12211673 um... ok?
anyway i cant wait to see it, they always turn out well
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12209618 I know what it's based on, I'm talking about the actual design of the pokemon. It's just a scary face.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12211547 woah thats cool, it looks like its eyes are just empty sockets that you can see the starts through!
maybe try to emphasize that?
i like this btw
Anonymous
>>12211681 lol, thanks for the tips. I might have even got it eventually if I took a serious shot at it but I just figured it would be easier and look better to just shamelessly steal yours.
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
Quoted By:
>>12211732 Hehe, it's always easier.
You can achieve anything you want as long as you practice and try hard!
I keep folding over a piece of the hem and coming back to check messages. At this rate itll never get done.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12211758 To the retro dex it goes!
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12211758 I miss you gar n tea man
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
So I broke one of my personal rules by making this but FUCK IT
blondbomber
crap i was working on the water starter and now it looks like a blue charmander
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212040 lol it kinda is without the nose plate.
Anonymous
>>12211955 very nice
and um, dashing, is there something you want to talk about
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
>>12212058 MY LEGS HURT
PEOPLE ARE DUMB
Anonymous
Small change to make it more obvious it's wearing a mask?
blondbomber
When I was drawing Aguade all I could think about is how much it looks like an ocean iguana which I love to death! oh and this is just a rough and i was using a new program
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
>>12212126 That's what it is, sir~ A marine iguana.
Anonymous
>>12212080 my jaw dropped
its wings look a bit like balloons, try toning down the glare or making them see through
seriously this is god tier
>>12212069 alright, well using caps lock isnt gonna educate them
what are these dumb people doing?
>>12212126 its been voted to focus attention on his final evo rather than his first evo
that little guy is really loved as is
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212080 It's.... it's beautiful. I don't even words.
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12212080 that is badass, I don't know who you are but I like you
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212145 >what it's supposed to be Even just adding a frilly mane, I think it would go a long way to boost the recognizability. Wish we could tack some on the awesome wrestler guy.
blondbomber
>>12212146 oh I had no idea this is my frist time here
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212080 Soooo, can THIS be our official design...?
Anonymous
>>12212165 haha, that really means a lot. It started as my attempt at a sugi, but I couldn't get the blending, the lines, or the texturing right.
I'll post in a few minutes another version
Anonymous
Anonymous
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12212186 kinda looks more like Miyazaki art than it does Sugimori, but that in no way detracts from how cool it is. I'd definitely like to see the other versions you have.
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
>>12212146 I work at a theme park
And like
Sometimes people are just stupid. They go beyond full retard and make me question whether or not the human race, as a whole, deserves to breed a new generation.
I had to give an in-depth explanation of bowling. As in the "roll the ball into the white things" part of it.
Anonymous
>>12212176 oh is it?
well welcome artist
yeah we are in the process of finalizing a good deal of these mons
i recomend doing the hampster evo, i think its the furthest from being done of all the mons we need for the first demo
the approval rating is being checked now but last time it was really low so get creative, and ask for any info or check its page on the wiki
http://capx.wikia.com/wiki/Guinea_Pig_2 Anonymous
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
Quoted By:
also different version
Anonymous
>>12212241 no reason to get all steroid emo
there are alot of retards out there
>>12212193 its cute but i think the spikes of our current work better
good art btw
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
Quoted By:
>>12212289 But these people are BAD. And I live in New Jersey, so I already have low standards. But my biggest problem are these legs pains, holy shit.
Anonymous
blondbomber
Fire kolbold was hard to do because their is no info on him! In the kolbold baby info it said that it spends its whole live underground so I drew fire with almost no eyes.
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
>>12212126 Amazing. Think you could try the middle stage new artist?
DUNKYWUNKR !EA1kcDpTxA
Quoted By:
>>12212370 THATS A KOBOLD. Darken the lines and color it. That is a canine kobold. I love you
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212370 someone made it less dog but still right. blond is the chosen one.
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12212370 something that just came to mind
where does the prevo get the fur for his cape?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212370 the fire kobold is when it decides to venture out of its cave and into the sunlight. The steel evolution is completely Eyeless, so exaggerate the eyes if possible since thats the big difference.
I'm guessing the evolution method is location based; I.e., fire if outdoors/building, steel if cave/underwater/Ilex-like forest
blondbomber
>>12212371 yeah I'll draw him,right now he looks like a really bad digimon
Anonymous
>>12212146 With all this positive feedback, I think I'm going to have to make another pass at sugi ing. Pump it up to eleven.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212370 like i said
>>12212249 ask for info
the kobold baby is a cave dwelling little guy (look up kobold) who either stays in his cave, goes blind, stays bipedal, gets big fore arms, gets steel type (visualy similar to mole)
OR he ventures out of the cave, develops great eyesight, goes quadraped, gets big hind legs, gets fire type (visualy similar to canine)
make the eyes not blind and its great
Anonymous
>>12212398 From the backs of those that have wronged him.
blondbomber
>>12212398 from a dead fire kolbold
Anonymous
>>12212412 Annnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnd we're done here.
Actually, the shading on the neck seems a bit weird.its not very gradual looking and instead just darkens in waves.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212424 Great advice, anon! You've saved the day yet again from the scourge of tripfaggotry that's ruining your precious legion and anonymity! Good for you, hero to all!
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12212421 >>12212420 it's like cubone all over again
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212409 i wouldnt, his evo is not decided and thats a big part of it
id do something like the guiny pig that is at rock bottom atm
>>12212412 i came
fantastic
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12212423 That's actually how all of the shades are, but the face that the neck is obvious about it does mean there's a problem. This should be better
(same anon)
Nondell !PJ.OdWT5NU
>>12212492 Have you made art for gen /vp/ before? This is great.
Anonymous
>>12212492 what the fuck is up with those eyes
Anonymous
I'm going to start on a backsprite for Florresum, but I wanted to check something first. Are the only differences that the male has red cheeks and the female has a puffed chest?
Anonymous
>>12212513 Never vector art before. But this is pretty much just shading on a slighty modified pose from the official art. I work great with reference but I'm not always that good from scratch.
Actually, I did post this before as a posible villain logo.
Anonymous
>>12212289 The percentage approval doesn't seem to think the same
Anonymous
>>12212559 the percent does not say
"fluff is better than spikes"
and many like the prevo but not the evo
Anonymous
>>12212516 Forgot to change them.
Nondell !PJ.OdWT5NU
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212553 honestly i didnt know about the puff chest
but yeah i think thats it
and im glad its being made
>>12212591 this is why our fakemon game is best fakemon game
Anonymous
>>12212590 well then how does this suit ya
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212591 remember when people wanted this thing culled way back when?
yeah fuck them
You are doing god's work anon, you should try your hand at other pokes too.
Local Moose Friend !MHCNz5M/Cw
Quoted By:
>>12212625 It kinda looks like he's made of clouds...
Anonymous
>>12212555 >when you see it Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12212591 Great job so far, but you got the red and white on the head backwards.
Nondell !PJ.OdWT5NU
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212625 OLD MAN WINTER!
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12212591 very nice.
>>12212642 that was intentional from what I read, to make the face look more like a mask
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212625 ok you have my vote
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212658 dam thats p cool
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
>>12212658 I'm with you there, while
>>12212625 is pretty cool, I do prefer the
>>12208882 design
Anonymous
>>12212642 That's what started this whole thing.
>>12212080 With the white head you can't tell it's a mask.
I can change it back though.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12212694 i really dont think its supposed to be a mask
its a pseudo mask, its not like you can take it off
this one looks/is better
Anonymous
>>12212289 Also spike design
Anonymous
>>12212726 also the picture
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
So these are the two new designs we have
Anonymous
What is this supposed to be? (also typing)
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212730 ahahahahahahaha
in a good way.
I like puffy better. Looks like snow/clouds/hair
Spikes just look like hair or static electricity.
Puff would get my vote. AS would old man winter.
Wish evo wasn't so perfectly humanoid though. Maybe tweak some proportions?
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12212759 >inb4 people jump shit Lets try not to scare off new blood
http://capx.wikia.com/wiki/Kobold Anonymous
>>12212759 please god do not attempt to redesign them if you are new
its a sensitive and complex subject
also avoid starters
we appreciate new friends if they are helpful but try to do something else first
Anonymous
>>12212782 So does it not need a redesign
Anonymous
>>12212792 shit bro, I'm just following
>>12205656 Anonymous
>>12212797 i know but you should start with something more straight forward
Anonymous
>>12212817 such as? Already took a shot at the troll
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212793 Everything without a green arrow in the starter image needs to be adjusted.
But those particular guys have been a clusterfuck for us, so we're recommending you try something else first.
Although I personally don't see the harm.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12212874 The hat guinea pigs? I see nooooo fuckin way around them. Those designs are the best you're gonna get with those. I guess I could keep the guinea pig idea, but drop the hat?
Anonymous
>>12212852 well the guinea pig evo (not the prevo, hes probably finished) is probably what needs the most attention
but any but those three, the starters, and any that are about to be final (theres a survey right now to decide whats final)
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212886 Can't think of anything for the evo?
Everyone seems to love the prevo, so you can ignore it.
Gunvarrel !Oq/9NMk1yg
Quoted By:
>>12212886 The prevo is perfect, IMO. It's just the evo that needs work, and there's plenty that hasn't been explored with the concept yet.
Anonymous
>>12212887 fuck i'm having trouble keeping track of what people want redesigned
I'll try the evo
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212398 From its dead mom.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212886 well you cant get rid of the hat, thats the whole damn point
but i think there is stuff to try with it
>>12212907 yeah i know, were in the process of finalizing really important stuff
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212886 It could grow a sweater.
Those hats are like alpaca fur right? I always thought it was a shame the evo wasn't a llama.
I know we have llama. I just saying.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12212939 See, this fucker has talent.
Just because he's new doesn't mean he can't sit at the big people table.
Let him draw anything he wants, I say.
Anonymous
>>12212939 that hood looked weird
>>12212953 thanks dood
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212960 oh... That's not what i was expecting at all.
You've shattered my expectations, good friend, that shit is good!
Anonymous
More camel like I don't wanna actually draw something if the sketch isn't liked
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212984 that's pretty cool but i preferred
>>12212960 Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212797 Do what you want, the worst that could happen is you piss off some obsessive compulsive fuck like dash.
Anonymous
alright your good as hell, if you have ideas for the kobold then heres info: the first form: a baby kobold (look up kobolds) a cave dwelling gremlin like dark type physically half way between his evos it can either stay in its cave and become its steel evo, or it can venture out and become its fire evo the steel form: visually based on a mole blind large fore arms bipedal the fire form: visually based on a canine great eyesight large back legs quadraped there are many designs that are being surveyed right now and its likely one will be finalized the steel type is pretty loved by alot of people, so focus on the others
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213011 oh i should clarify its dark type to dual dark/steel and dark/fire
>>12212960 >>12212984 these are really cool btw
Anonymous
>>12208479 What a lame concept. How exactly does she tie in with the ground type?
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12213028 >how do sandcastles tie in with the ground type Ok i know it's technically rock, but still.
Also
>implying their occupations/hobbies have to match their type blondbomber
Ok is this better? I can gid rid of the red I was just trying to some "fire"
Anonymous
>wants to draw kobolds >no way noob, you'll fuck them up >draws really good >please do the kobolds! I'm not criticizing anyone, but this turn of events is fucking hilarious.
Anonymous
>>12213051 eh, can you really blame em?
I mean, the kobolds are probably one of the hardest concepts we have.
>>12213046 >fat, bipedal Zoroark Anonymous
>>12213046 stop putting ss, its faggy and defeats the purpose of this project, you aint getting credit
Gunvarrel !Oq/9NMk1yg
Quoted By:
>>12212939 >>12212960 >it's a hood my heart
Anonymous
>>12213040 How is it any different from a swimmer doing water type?
Although if that really is all she's bringing to the table I don't she isn't being mopped up by muddy buddy. That guy is bandwagon.
Anonymous
>>12213066 I'm a mudbuddy guy myself, but i'd be cool with Sandra.
She's pretty simple, but the sandcastle thing could work really well.
Imagine her E4 room being a large, elaborate sandcastle-arena with massive sand sculptures like that skink one in that picture.
blondbomber
>>12213057 >>12213060 wow at frist all I get is draw kolbold and now
and now you guys are pretty much telling me to fuck off
Anonymous
>>12213099 oh boy, we have another one.
blondbomber
>>12213106 Fuck off and draw your own damn pokemon then
Anonymous
>>12213134 I would, but these guys are faggots and don't accept sprites as redesigns.
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
You see, my friends, this is one of the major problems with the project we're self-destructive. A talented person comes along, and if one goddamn thing they do isn't received well, they're crucified. blondbomber, I liked your work. Ignore people who don't give constructive criticism - their opinion is worthless. Listen to people that are trying to help you rather than hurt you.
Anonymous
>>12213082 i also think that sand is a good take on ground type
>>12213099 settle down, its a couple guys giving feedback in a rude way
>>12213106 >NINJA v2 >>12213146 you can always make sprite redesigns and have someone make art for it, im not good but i can draw
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213134 Sigh.
I really like your stuff but If you can't take a few cheap shots...
4chan isn't really for the light of heart.
You gotta take the good with the bad, it's the nature of the beast.
Anonymous
>>12213161 >A talented person comes along, and if one goddamn thing they do isn't received well, they're crucified. Fuck you Dashing. We said it wasn't good and he started blubbering like a little babby.
It's not like we started attacking him out of nowhere like that stupid incident with Base.
This guy was just one of those drawfags that pop in here and expect everyone to suck their dick because they can make clean drawings.
Anonymous
>/vp/magg scares off yet another drawfriend This really needs to stop happening.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213190 This. We're not on deviantart.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213202 >drawfriends freak out on 4chan if we loose what makes 4chan 4chan then this game will lose the whole point of it
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
>>12213190 >Fuck you Sure bby call me sometime
>We said it wasn't good and he started blubbering like a little babby. Sometimes it's not what you say, it's how you say it. No constructive criticism was given to him, and the posts basically were insults.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
I'd like to think most of us try to respect people's feelings, but it isn't exactly a requirement here.>inb4 majority don't I said I'd LIKE to think But dude, you've already recieved like a 90% approval rate on your stuff at least. Ignore the assholes.
Anonymous
>>12213166 >you can always make sprite redesigns and have someone make art for it, Oh yeah, i know all about that, it's how the "sleek" erace being surveyed came into being.
>>12213202 It's not exactly like we're in short supply. All we ask is that you be a little humble and of course, have a little bit of thick skin (that last part is just a general thing for this site).
>>12213217 I said it looked like a fucking quadripedal Zoroark (though, mistakenly said bipedal) because that's literally what it fucking looked like, all the way down to the fucking face and red streaks in its hair.
I didnt have to write a fucking essay to get my point across. It was pretty obvious it looked 90% like Zoroark.
And when you respond with
>let's see you do better! You bet your ass you wont be welcome here anymore.
Anonymous
Anonymous
I have NO idea how to color shit or whatever, so if someone wants to do different colors or something be my guest.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213244 you have my vote
Anonymous
>>12213217 I'm a sensitive draw fag whose been crushed multiple times
>fat, bipedal Zoroark This is the thread that somehow coined It sucks, it's shit, get rid of it. Where the term "cull" has lost all meaning. Where a design gets dragged through the dirt just because some people claim other people want to fap to it.
It would be awesome if the atmosphere was at least inviting, but let's not kid our selves. This is adult swim, and anything goes.
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
>>12213239 The only Zoroark I see in it is the red streaks.
It's 3 in the morning, I'm tired, and I didn;t realize I didn't say this until now: I'm not saying that guy was right, but what I am saying is we can handle these things better.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213249 IT'S CONDESSA TIME!
Nah, but the colour scheme and pattern you used in
>>12213244 is fine.
Matches the prevo nicely
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
Quoted By:
>>12213253 The problem with that is that even in adult swim, you don't piss in the pool. You could have been in the pool for hours, but if you piss in it, you should be kicked out.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12213249 Could you try giving it earflaps?
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
Quoted By:
>>12213262 A man walks down the street in that hat, people know he's not afraid of anything.
Anonymous
>>12213261 Just because you don't agree with someone else's criticism it doesn't make that criticism invalid. He gave a reason he didn't like it, that's more than you'd expect for most of 4chan.
Anonymous
This new guy is AWESOME. Where have you been, sir?!
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
>>12213285 > If you do not like a design give constructive criticism so we know best how to change it! That's right out of the OP.
Just because the majority of 4chan does the opposite does not justify us doing it. I like to imagine we can at least PRETEND to be mature for the three seconds it takes to post in this thread.
Then again, maybe I'm just a faggot.
Anonymous
>>12213261 it wasn't even handled that poorly anyway.
i said it looked too much like zoroark.
That's it.
Now to someone who's not from deviantart, they'd see that and say, "oh shit, it kinda does" and work towards making it not look like Zoroark.
Now if i said something like
>Wow that was so fucking shitty, looks like Zoroark drawn by Matt Groening. Leave this project forever, go kill yourself You'd have a point. But my post was ~mildly~ rude at most.
Then there was the other guy who told him to stop signing that shit because he wasn't getting credit. Sure, he called him a faggot, but that's the most fucking used word on this site. You take "faggot" with the tiniest grain of salt here.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12212711 It's a mask the same way ankillosaur has a mask. But by having it the same color as the skin it might as well not be there at all.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213294 I did some drawing a while back, none got voted in. People liked my desert mirage pokemon, though.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213304 He said that it looked too much like zoroark. That means that he thinks it would be better if it didn't look too much like zoroark. That's what he thinks needs to be changed, maybe you are a faggot.
Dia !7zfFcmVqWQ
Quoted By:
>>12213316 I love it
I'll take two
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213304 youdensemotherfucker.jpg
I told him what was wrong with it.
It doesnt need to be this huge drawn out post telling him every single detail.
I didn't just say "hurr its shit get rid of it". I told him my biggest problem with it, it's resemblance to Zoroark.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213161 That's just part of being an artist, you aren't always going to always get happy positive criticism/comments, especially on the internet and especially on 4chan.
Anonymous
Anonymous
I'm not really satisfied with the current color scheme of the guinea pig prevo, so I tried different options. I also tried to simplify the design a little. Thoughts?
Anonymous
>>12213335 well whatever is picked, the evo needs to match of course.
Can it be condessa time now?
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
>>12213306 I see what you're saying. I still disagree, mildly, but I understand you a lot better. The situation could have been handled a little better on both sides, and that guy definitely over-reacted.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>12213343 Pic related.
>>12213342 Id rather see our new local hero tackle solacari. Playtime's over mother fucker.
Anonymous
>>12213316 Now without the string but with hair like this one? I love were this is going
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
>>12213354 I don't get it.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213346 hahaha, i meant it in a good way.
Fuzzy gnome and fuzzy hatcritter are fine.
And even if all you can do is poof balls, they is some fine looking poofters.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213342 please be gentle
Anonymous
>>12213350 One of our mons.
Not too long ago we were brainstorming colour schemes and ended up with like 50 different ones.
Then the same thing happened to Magowl, another one of our pokemon, a few days ago.
Anyway, here's some lineart if anyone wants to do some colour scheming.
Anonymous
>>12213366 > that guy definitely over-reacted. Anonymous
DashingHero !!jDn6qImItZZ
Quoted By:
>>12213374 It's late, I'm tired, THINKING IS NOT MY FORTE RIGHT NOW.
Thanks for explaining.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213378 that's perfect. thanks a lot! I love this design
Anonymous
>>12213350 >http://capx.wikia.com/wiki/CAPX_Wiki We got a wiki if you want to brush up.
If that sounded condescending it wasn't meant to be.
>>12213373 If little guy is like the size of a persons head (which I always asumed (not just because of the hat)) Wouldn't that make big brother like bear sized? I'd prefer it the size of a large dog IMHO.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213394 Even if he is bear sized, I still want to give him a hug.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>12213394 Well sizes aren't final. And i agree with you, the evo should be around the size of a large dog. I just couldnt be bothered to change the dimensions of the pic. It was just easier to scale down the prevo.
Anonymous
Anonymous
So is this guy like, firefighter based?
Anonymous