>>14531506>No it's not. Are you seriously pretending to be that little boy catching pokemon and petting them and shit? That's fucking autistic.Well, yeah, some people are, and it isn't autistic, it's the entire purpose behind a silent protagonist. I didn't really have the mental capacity to do that when I was a kid, but I do it in gens II-V now. The fact that Red is an actual character now that didn't get thrown away ruins it for first gen.
I have always played as the girl in my second run-throughs, however.
I honestly think you're looking too deeply into the reasons behind these choices. Some people just say "Sure, I'll be the girl/boy. Who cares."